With support from the University of Richmond

History News Network

History News Network puts current events into historical perspective. Subscribe to our newsletter for new perspectives on the ways history continues to resonate in the present. Explore our archive of thousands of original op-eds and curated stories from around the web. Join us to learn more about the past, now.

A New History Celebrates Brooklyn’s Heights, and Depths Image

The Once and Future City
By Thomas J. Campanella

Years ago, when I lived in the Greenpoint section of Brooklyn, I invested in a book of neighborhood walking tours so I could enlighten family members who came to visit. I discovered that I liked walking backward down Franklin Street, pointing out landmarks built by whale-oil magnates in the 1800s. Of course, were I to walk the same streets today, the tour would include landmarks relevant to my own history, many of them now gone: “This New York Sports Club was once a crazy Polish nightclub I reviewed for New York magazine’s website! The waitresses dressed like Paris Hilton and carried neon-lit trays full of vodka drinks.” And so forth.

Brooklyn’s history, both macro and micro, is as specific and varied as its inhabitants. A single block can contain centuries’ worth of information, memories and relics left by heroes and villains alike. The prospect of writing a history of such a multilayered city must have been daunting even for as qualified a fourth-generation Brooklynite as Thomas J. Campanella, who lives in Marine Park and teaches history at Cornell. Where should a historian focus, given such a wealth of data and experience and lives lived in close proximity? Thankfully, Campanella takes a practical approach: Instead of attempting a chronology that traces themes or communities through the decades and centuries, he treats each chapter as a self-contained deep dive into a particular part of the borough, describing how that place came to be — and, in some cases, how it ended up demolished or abandoned.

For the purposes of this illuminating and sometimes maddening book, the history of Brooklyn is a series of experiments with unpredictable and uneven results.


Read entire article at New York Times