George Mason University's
History News Network

Roundup: Talking About History


This is where we excerpt articles about history that appear in the media. Among the subjects included on this page are: anniversaries of historical events, legacies of presidents, cutting-edge research, and historical disputes.

SOURCE: Salon (11-19-07)

Paging Clark Hoyt. Is the New York Times public editor paying attention to the brawl that's broken out on the page next to his? For the last few weeks we've semi-enjoyed the spectacle of liberals Paul Krugman and Bob Herbert battling with conservative David Brooks and Ronald Reagan biographer Lou Cannon over the meaning of Reagan's 1980 presidential campaign stop in Philadelphia, Miss. The home of the Neshoba County Fair is infamous as the site where three young civil rights workers, Andrew Goodman, Michael Schwerner and James Chaney, were murdered in 1964.

Now with Krugman coming out swinging for another round, it's time to say: Enough! Why doesn't the Times assign a reporter to check out competing claims about the meaning of Reagan's visit? I have a strong hunch Krugman and Herbert's side would win, but either way, the latest column by Krugman virtually guarantees a Brooks rejoinder, and life is too short to have to parse this controversy indefinitely. That's what...

Tuesday, November 20, 2007 - 18:03

SOURCE: Commentary blog (11-12-07)

Roger Kimball, one of our finest critics, has delivered a devastating dissection of Norman Mailer’s overrated career, which consisted of political posturing and juvenile behavior interspersed with the production of mediocre novels—at best. (Kimball’s critique may be found here.)

I have very little to add beyond a few thoughts on the book that launched Mailer’s career—The Naked and the Dead, written in 1948 when its author was a 25-year-old unknown. Kimball is dead right when he describes this work as “pretentious,” not particularly “well-crafted,” and lacking in narrative “momentum.” Kimball writes, “Its heavy-handed psychologizing and use of four-letter words were thought smart in 1948; most contemporary readers will find them quaint if not downright embarrassing.” That was certainly my reaction upon reading The Naked and the Dead years ago. What was all the fuss about, I...


Tuesday, November 20, 2007 - 14:49

SOURCE: EdNews (11-20-07)

[Mr. Fitzhugh is the founder of the Concord Review.]

The National Endowment for the Arts has released a new study of studies of the decline of reading in the United States. Some kinds of reading were apparently not considered.

Zeus and Mnemosyne [Memory] were the parents of the nine Muses. Calliope was the muse of epic poetry, Clio was the muse of history, Erato was the muse of love poetry, Euterpe was the muse of music, Melpomene was the muse of tragedy, Polyhymnia was the muse of sacred poetry, Terpsichore was the muse of dance, Thalia was the muse of comedy, and Urania was the muse of astronomy.

Of these nine, two are now off the reservation. Urania has clearly taken Astronomy over to the Science side of the Arts, and Clio has had the misfortune of presiding over history and nonfiction, and so, at least for the National Endowment for the Arts, has evidently lost her status among the Arts.

In 2004, the National...

Tuesday, November 20, 2007 - 14:11

SOURCE: Counterpunch (11-19-07)

[Heather Gray produces "Just Peace" on WRFG-Atlanta 89.3 FM covering local, regional, national and international news. She can be reached at hmcgray@earthlink.net ]

In a recent article posted on Counterpunch entitled "When Capitalists Get a Free Ride " (November 3-4, 2007) I made reference to W.E.B. Du Bois having joined and left the Communist Party in the mid-20th century due to his frustration over the lack of inclusion of a racial analysis or understanding. It is true that Du Bois spent considerable effort attempting to educate the white communists about racial oppression and became disenchanted with the party's organizing tactics, but I need to make a correction. A fairer assessment is that his views on communism and economic thought fluctuated and evolved over time. Du Bois, who was a profound student and proponent of Marxian thought and who was accused of being a communist, did not actually officially...

Tuesday, November 20, 2007 - 01:39

SOURCE: FindLaw.com (11-16-07)

Amid a slow, low-boiling, and mostly Texas-based controversy regarding the potential location of a future George W. Bush Presidential Library, a significant issue regarding such a future institution is being completely overlooked: Should there be federal support of the Bush Presidential Library, in light of the fact that President Bush has refused to comply with the 1978 Presidential Records Act?

Presidential libraries and records are on my mind because I attended a conference sponsored by all presidential libraries that was held at Franklin Roosevelt's Library in Hyde Park, New York. The conference addressed Presidents and the Supreme Court, but a question about presidential records arose during my panel. In addition, in conversations with presidential library professionals (of all political persuasions), I found that they are deeply troubled by Bush's and Cheney's actions regarding presidential records.

Previously, I have written about how Bush's Executive...

Monday, November 19, 2007 - 00:57

SOURCE: Mother Jones blog (MoJo) (11-15-07)

Richard Nixon, say what you will of this criminally minded president, was a keen observer of politics. But he seems to have underestimated fellow Republican Ronald Reagan (or the American public). On the morning of November 17, 1971, Nixon, while meeting with National Security Adviser Henry Kissinger in the Oval Office, shared a few sharp--and negative--comments about California Governor Ronald Reagan, who had recently told Kissinger that Nixon had a "real problem" with conservatives who believed Nixon was not sufficiently hawkish on foreign policy matters.

For years, the Presidential Recordings Program of the Miller Center of Public Affairs at the University of Virginia has been transcribing and analyzing the tape recordings Nixon secretly made in the White House. Even though it's been 33 years since a disgraced Nixon left office, his tapes are still being processed by the National Archives, and the Miller Center has only recently gotten to the tape of this...

Monday, November 19, 2007 - 00:47

SOURCE: AHA Perspectives (11-1-07)

[HNN Editor: The focus of this article is on the Civil War.]

... Between 1933, when Franklin D. Roosevelt transferred the Civil War battlefields from the War Department to the Department of the Interior, and the late 1990s, the NPS avoided all mention of the causes of the war in its exhibits, films, and publications. Eighty years after the 50th reunion at Gettysburg in 1913, the agency still adhered to Governor William Mann's admonition that "we came here, I say, not to discuss what caused the war of 1861–65, but to talk over the events of the battle here as man to man."3 In a small exhibit inside Fort Sumter installed in 1995, the National Park Service first connected slavery with the coming of the war.

Three years later, battlefield superintendents decided, as the country approached the 150th anniversary of the war, that it was time the NPS began presenting the causes of the war to the visiting public. Once word of the meeting and its "radical...

Friday, November 16, 2007 - 18:51

SOURCE: National Review (11-12-07)

... “One minute I saw young men who looked like us — just wearing different uniforms — walking across a quiet field,” [my Uncle Romney, a veteran at Normandy] told me before he died a few years ago. “The next minute, they were running and screaming and being ripped apart and burned.”

My uncles’ stories are similar to those of so many other World War II-era veterans (now numbering less than three million). But each story is also unique — a special narrative-expansion of recorded history, and we are losing them at a rate of over 1,000 per day.

But it’s not just the veterans of World War II: There are some 17 million living American war veterans — from World War I through Iraq and Afghanistan — and the Library of Congress’s Veterans History Project is gathering as many of those unique stories as possible before they are lost to history: doing so through family and friend-conducted audio and video-taped interviews with veterans.

“The largest oral...

Friday, November 16, 2007 - 13:58

SOURCE: Butterfliesandwheels Website (11-13-07)

[Allen Esterson is the author of Seductive Mirage: An Exploration of the Work of Sigmund Freud.]

The story so far: In 2003 the US Public Broadcasting Service first broadcast the documentary “Einstein’s Wife” (co-sponsored by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation), which purports to present evidence that Einstein’s first wife, Mileva Marić, was a brilliant mathematician and scientist who co-authored his epoch-making 1905 papers, and whose major contributions to his work had been carefully concealed throughout the twentieth century. In fact, as Alberto A. Martínez has demonstrated,[1] the film is a travesty of the historical record. I belatedly came across the film and accompanying PBS website in late 2005, and, following a close examination of the historical evidence, in March 2006 I submitted a complaint to the PBS Ombudsman, providing documentation of the falsehoods, misconceptions and tendentious misrepresentations in the film[2] and on the website[3].

After...


Wednesday, November 14, 2007 - 13:50

SOURCE: Moscow Times (11-14-07)

[Roy Medvedev, a historian and former Soviet dissident, is the author of "The October Revolution" and "Let History Judge: The Origins and Consequences of Stalinism."]

A plethora of anniversaries is arriving in Russia. This month commemorates the 90th anniversary of the October Revolution and the 25th anniversary of the death of Leonid Brezhnev. Next month will see the 16th anniversary of the Soviet Union's disintegration. Only by understanding that first event, however, can we understand the others.

The October Revolution has always had many critics. The philosopher Ivan Shmelev named it "the great beating of Russia." Pre-Revolutionary writer Vasily Rozanov called it "The Massacre of Russia." Countless authors view it as a tragedy that broke the flow of history and destroyed the country's best people.

But the Revolution also has its apologists, for whom it marked the beginning of a new era in history, a...

Tuesday, November 13, 2007 - 22:54

SOURCE: National Review (11-9-07)

These are tough times for, and in, America. We are at war, and we find that war highly controversial. Many of our political leaders have record-low approval ratings and too many are held in ignominy. Washington — our nation’s capital — is held in contempt, as a laugh line by comedians. But perhaps a greater tragedy than all of this is that we seem to no longer have any kind of reference point. For indeed, we are not living in the toughest of times, we are not living in the worst of times, nor are we fighting the toughest of wars. But try telling that to our nation’s young people; too many of them absorb too much of the negativism taught by our culture to know this.

The truth is, we’ve been in far worse shape in terms of what we’ve had to endure in this country — but we may not have been in far worse shape in terms of what we know about our country. Too many of our high-school students do not graduate high school, and of those who do, too many do not know the basic facts of...

Tuesday, November 13, 2007 - 22:11

SOURCE: Claremont Review of Books (11-13-07)

The Reagan book industry is shifting into high gear these days with several important new perspectives on our 40th president and his statecraft. Midge Decter wrote in 1991 that "[i]t will, one day, take a truly gifted writer, perhaps a novelist, to solve the puzzle of such a man." Edmund Morris essentially tried this approach, and made a fool of himself. The new passel of books adds fuel to the debates over Reagan, though it may be wondered whether the best guide to the man isn't still Reagan himself, in the form of his newly published diaries.

Romantic Imagination

Overall, the flood of books is highly encouraging, especially John Patrick Diggins's Ronald Reagan: Fate, Freedom, and the Making of History, which, except for the diaries, has attracted the most attention. The great fear of conservatives when the Gipper left office was that the liberal professoriate would "Coolidgize" him. And starting with Bill Clinton's 1992 campaign,...

Tuesday, November 13, 2007 - 21:07

SOURCE: American Conservative (11-5-07)

In the years leading up to Barry Goldwater's death, conservatives wondered what had happened to their hero. They had wondered for some time, actually—since at least 1976, when Goldwater endorsed moderate incumbent Gerald Ford over insurgent conservative Ronald Reagan for the Republican presidential nomination. Back then, conservative activist John Lofton suggested Goldwater must not be in his right mind,"still in an ether fog" from recent hip replacement surgery:"Possessed of all his faculties, he would never say the things he has been saying about Reagan."

But by the early '90s, there could be no doubt: Goldwater damned the Religious Right at every opportunity, spoke out for abortion rights, and not only supported letting gays serve openly in the military, but even lent his name to an effort to pass federal antidiscrimination laws for homosexuals—quite a turnabout for a man who as a senator had once stood on federalist grounds against the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

Goldwater's...


Tuesday, November 13, 2007 - 19:11

SOURCE: City Journal (11-12-07)

[Myron Magnet is the author of The Dream and the Nightmare: The Sixties’ Legacy to the Underclass. He is City Journal’s editor-at-large and was its editor from 1994 through 2006. ]

In the summer of 1786, still mourning his beloved wife’s death four years earlier and soon to begin sleeping with her 15-year-old half-sister, his slave Sally Hemings, Thomas Jefferson fell in love with a beautiful English painter named Maria Cosway. Head over heels in love: for the 43-year-old minister to France tried to impress the twentysomething Maria by jumping a fence, and the resulting dislocated wrist troubled him the rest of his life. With his good hand, he wrote Maria a 4,500-word love letter, a half-mock philosophical “dialogue” in which his “Head” contends that he should have stuck to “intellectual pleasures” that “ride serene and sublime above the concerns of this mortal world,” while his “Heart” replies, in highly charged terms, that the happiness of love is worth the pain of loss, and...


Monday, November 12, 2007 - 23:25

SOURCE: American Prospect (11-12-07)

If you live in the United States and want to start a war, the first step is to compare the foreign leader to Adolf Hitler. This technique was on display in a recent PBS NewsHour debate between Norman Podhoretz, a foreign policy adviser to Republican presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani, and Fareed Zakaria, editor of Newsweek International. At least four times during the debate, Podhoretz likened the clerical regime in Tehran to the Nazis. He argued that there is a danger that Iran may"replace [the existing global order] with a new order dominated by Iran and ruled by the religio-political culture of Islamofascism."

This is a ridiculous claim, and it exalts Iran to status it does not deserve. Podhoretz and his confreres have a sad and curious track record of crying wolf, seeing Hitlers and appeasement nearly everywhere. The danger of embracing the Munich analogy as a catch-all analytical tool for international politics is that it overstates the implications of each international...


Monday, November 12, 2007 - 23:17

[David W. Blight is the director of Yale University's Gilder Lehrman Center for the Study of Slavery, Resistance, and Abolition and a professor of American history. Among his books is Race and Reunion, which won the Frederick Douglass Prize, the Lincoln Prize, and the Bancroft Prize. He lives in New Haven, Connecticut.]

John Washington, a twenty-four-year-old urban slave in Fredericksburg, Virginia, escaped across the Rappahannock River to Union army lines in April 1862 by ingenuity, skillful deception, and courage. Through the chaos of war he found his way to a tenuous freedom in Washington, D.C. Wallace Turnage, a seventeenyear-old slave born in North Carolina, ran away four times from an Alabama cotton...

Monday, November 12, 2007 - 22:33

[Tom Brokaw is the author of four bestsellers: The Greatest Generation, The Greatest Generation Speaks, An Album of Memories, and A Long Way from Home. From 1976 to 1981 he anchored Today on NBC. He was the sole anchor and managing editor of NBC Nightly News with Tom Brokaw from 1983 to 2004. www.boom-brokaw.com ]

In 1962, I had an entry-level reporter's job at an Omaha television station. I had bargained to get a salary of one hundred dollars a week, because I didn't feel I could tell Meredith's doctor father I was making less. Meredith, who had a superior college record, couldn't find any work because, as one personnel director after another told her, "You're a young bride. If we hire you, you'll just get pregnant before long and want maternity leave."

In retrospect, the political and cultural climate in the early Sixties seems both a time of innocence and also like a sultry, still summer day in the Midwest...

Monday, November 12, 2007 - 22:10

SOURCE: Japan Focus (11-23-07)

This article is slightly adapted from a chapter by the late Fujiwara Akira, an emeritus professor at Hitotsubashi University until his death in 2003, which first appeared in Bob Tadashi Wakabayashi, ed., The Nanking Atrocity 1937-38: Complicating the Picture (New York and London: Berghahn Books, 2007). Fujiwara wrote one of two introductory chapters to this volume about the Nanking Massacre, the seventieth anniversary of which will be observed in December.

In this essay, Fujiwara provides a concise narrative of Japan’s decision to escalate the “China Incident” into a full-scale war by July 1937. This ultimately led to an assault on China’s wartime capital of Nanking by imperial armed forces, who captured it in December. Fujiwara also gives a trenchant, critical account of the Nanking Massacre (a.k.a. “the Rape of Nanking”), plus an admittedly partisan yet nonetheless fair analysis of right-wing views in Japan today that downplay or deny this atrocity. On this last point,...

Friday, November 9, 2007 - 19:26

Summary: On his radio show, Limbaugh claimed that the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth"were right on the money, and nobody has disproven anything they claimed in any of their ads, statements, written commentaries, or anything of the sort." In fact, most of the allegations the Swift Boat Veterans made about Sen. John Kerry's Vietnam War service during the 2004 presidential campaign have been thoroughly discredited, often by official military records, but also by the Swift Boat accusers themselves, who struggled to keep their stories straight.

On the November 7 broadcast of his nationally syndicated radio program, Rush Limbaugh claimed that the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth"were right on the money, and nobody has disproven anything they claimed in any of their ads, statements, written commentaries, or anything of the sort." Limbaugh made his comments on the same day reporter...


Friday, November 9, 2007 - 19:17

SOURCE: http://news.cincypost.com (11-9-07)

[Dan Hurley is the assistant vice president for history and research at the Cincinnati Museum Center. He is also the staff historian for Channel 12 News and the executive producer of Local 12 Newsmakers. Reach him at dhurley@cincymuseum.org.]

No painting by a Cincinnati artist is more arresting than Henry Farny's "The Song of the Talking Wire."

Owned by the Taft Museum of Art, downtown, the painting is on loan to the Cincinnati Art Museum as the opening image in its "Vanishing Frontier: Rookwood, Farny and the American Indian."

The 1904 painting depicts an Indian medicine man in the center of a snow-covered field leaning against a telegraph pole listening to the coded communications of a society whose relentless expansion over 400 years was on the verge of overwhelming its few remaining outposts.

Stylistically, "Talking Wire" is a wonderful opening for the 39...

Friday, November 9, 2007 - 18:52