George Mason University's
History News Network

Roundup: Talking About History


This is where we excerpt articles about history that appear in the media. Among the subjects included on this page are: anniversaries of historical events, legacies of presidents, cutting-edge research, and historical disputes.

SOURCE: http://www.nonbeliever.org/ (12-13-06)

The oath of office for United States president, as specified in Article II the constitution, does not include the phrase "so help me God." Contrary to the Architect of the Capital description of President Washington's Inaugural, the Joint Congressional Committee on Inaugural Ceremonies, Donald R. Kennon, Chief Historian, United States Capitol Historical Society, Dr. Marvin Kranz of the Library of Congress , the Public Broadcasting Service Online Newshour , the CNN Presidential Inaugural Timeline , the WETA Explore DC, the BBC Guide to 2001 inauguration ceremony, the History News Network, the C-SPAN in the classroom, Chief Justice Rehnquist writing for the majority in ELK GROVE UNIFIED SCHOOL DIST. V. NEWDOW, and Justice Scalia's dissent in McCREARY COUNTY, KENTUCKY, et al., PETITIONERS v. AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF KENTUCKY et al. and many others, there appears to be no reliably corroborated contemporary evidence that any president (excluding Jefferson Davis of the...

Wednesday, December 13, 2006 - 21:31

SOURCE: Chicago Sun-Times (12-10-06)

[Gene Healy is senior editor at the Cato Institute and co-author of "Power Surge: The Constitutional Record of George W. Bush."]

History may prove kinder to President Bush than the voters were on November 7. That, however, says less about the value of Bush's contributions than it does about the perverse conception of presidential greatness shared by historians who rank the presidents.
Such perennial rankings, based on surveys of historians and political scientists, tend to heavily favor imperial presidents. The winners in the game are the nation builders and war leaders. The losers are the presidential bores, the ones who "never did anything" other than preside over peace and prosperity without screwing it up.

Summing up the results of one of his surveys, the historian Arthur Schlesinger Sr. -- who in 1948 introduced the practice of presidential rankings -- noted that "mediocre presidents believed in negative government, in self-...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 22:24

SOURCE: WSJ (12-9-06)

... There are other reasons why some in Japan would be wary of [novelist Haruki Murakami]. The writer ventures where many Japanese fear to tread: exploring the nation's notorious World War II misadventures in Asia, a taboo subject in Japan and a continuous thorn in relations with neighboring China and South Korea. Mr. Murakami's widely acclaimed "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle," published in the U.S. in 1997, contains long, gruesome interpretations of the past.

In his book "Underground: The Tokyo Gas Attack and the Japanese Psyche," Mr. Murakami describes preparing to write "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle": "I did in-depth research into the so-called 1939 Nomonhan Incident, an aggressive incursion by Japanese forces into Mongolia. The more I delved into the records, the more aghast I became at the recklessness, the sheer lunacy of the Imperial Army's system of command. How had this pointless tragedy gone so wantonly overlooked in the course of...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 21:56

SOURCE: National Security Archive (12-12-06)

As Chile prepared to bury General Augusto Pinochet, the National Security Archive today posted a selection of declassified U.S. documents that illuminate the former dictator's record of repression. The documents include CIA records on Pinochet's role in the Washington D.C. car bombing that killed former Chilean ambassador Orlando Letelier and his American colleague Ronni Moffitt, Defense Intelligence Agency biographic reports on Pinochet, and transcripts of meetings in which Secretary of State Henry Kissinger resisted bringing pressure on the Chilean military for its human rights atrocities.

"Pinochet's death has denied his victims a final judicial reckoning," said Peter Kornbluh, who directs the Archive's Chile Documentation Project. "But the declassified documents do contribute to the ultimate verdict of history on his atrocities."

Most of the documents posted today are drawn from a collection of 24,000 declassified records that were...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 20:35

SOURCE: WSJ (12-12-06)

Augusto Pinochet died on Sunday at the age of 91, more than 18 years after he agreed to a 1988 plebiscite that turned him out of power. The standard Pinochet narrative is to emphasize the loss of liberty during the 17 years he ruled the country as a military dictator. The real story is more complicated.

Though General Pinochet became a devil symbol of the international left, he was a far more complex figure and cannot be understood apart from the global Cold War conflict of which he and his country were a part. Pinochet's legacy is a paradox--a long string of them.

He took power in a coup in 1973, but ultimately he created an environment where democratic institutions would prevail. He is responsible for the death and torture that occurred on his watch, but had Salvador Allende succeeded in turning Chile into another Cuba, many more might have died.





Late in life it emerged that he had probably stashed millions in personal bank...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 20:31

SOURCE: FrontpageMag.com (12-12-06)

[David Bedein is the bureau chief of the Israel Resource News Agency, located at the Beit Agron International Press Center in Jerusalem.]

On Monday, the Israeli government issued vehement denunciation of the conference convened by the Iranian government in Teheran to promote the denial of the mass murder of the Jews in World War II, in an act of holocaust denial. Our news agency asked the spokespeople of the government of Israel if they would also denounce the leader of the Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas, also known as Abu Mazen, for the holocaust denial which has been an integral part of his legacy.

However, the government of Israel would issue no such denunciation of Abbas, who wrote his doctorate in 1982 in Moscow, at the Institute for Oriental Studies. The institute was headed by Yevgeny Primakov, a Jew, an Arabist, an avowed friend of Saddam Hussein and other Arab rulers, and eventually the prime minister of Russia. Of all these qualities, Abu Mazen...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 20:09

SOURCE: Democracy: A Journal of Ideas (12-13-06)

[kevin mattson is a professor of history at Ohio University and author, most recently, of Upton Sinclair and the Other American Century.]

In the run-up to the 2006 elections, the past became the present political weapon of choice. Everything in politics, it seems, has a historical analogy. Consider first a speech this past summer by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld before a gathering of the American Le- gion. It revolved around an analogy between the appeasement of fascism in the 1930s and the critics of the Iraq war. Both then and today, he said, appeasers hold a belief that “if only the growing threats . . . could be accommodated, then the carnage . . . could be avoided.” Or take a recent column by Slate Editor Jacob Weisberg that compared Ned Lamont’s victory over Joe Lieberman in Connect- icut’s Democratic senatorial primary to the 1972 choice of George McGovern, a “naïve and honorable anti-war idealist,” as the Democratic presidential candi- date. McGovern...


Tuesday, December 12, 2006 - 18:15

SOURCE: NYT (12-11-06)

Aeneas, as far as we can see, is spared the trauma of a hero’s death, the kind of prophesied calamity that brought Achilles down at the height of his powers. Instead, Aeneas is last seen, at the close of Virgil’s Aeneid, triumphantly planting his iron sword “hilt-deep in his enemy’s heart.” But has there been a time in recent memory when Aeneas’s literary corpse has not been wrestled over, when this Trojan warrior, brought to such vivid life by Virgil, has really been able to rest in peace?

Read now Robert Fagles’s new pulsing, lyrical translation of the Aeneid (Viking), with its eloquent mixture of high rhetoric and conversational ease, and see too if — as arguments rage over war and peace, civilization and barbarism — Aeneas stands a chance.

He suffers the fate of having an unsettled place in the pantheon of heroes because Virgil gives him a far grander role to play than Homer’s supra-human figures had in the Iliad and the Odyssey. Aeneas is not just a...

Monday, December 11, 2006 - 23:06

SOURCE: American Heritage (12-1-06)

It’s hard to remember now, but the outcome of the 1991 Persian Gulf War stunned the world. Few people even at the Pentagon expected it to be as one-sided as it was. Before Operation Desert Storm, Iraq’s armed forces were widely seen as a formidable adversary, hardened by years of war against Iran and supplied with the best equipment Saddam Hussein’s oil riches could buy. Iraq had 900,000 soldiers—more than the U.S. Army—and they had had months to entrench themselves in Kuwait and southern Iraq. The Iraqis also had modern fighter planes, ballistic and cruise missiles, chemical stockpiles, and an elaborate air-defense network that would make Baghdad the most heavily defended city ever attacked from the air. Paeans to Iraqi combat prowess filled newspaper pages and television screens in the fall and winter of 1990.

And the U.S. armed forces? Weren’t they the bumblers who had been defeated outright by the Vietnamese and humiliated by the Cambodians, Iranians, and Lebanese in,...

Friday, December 8, 2006 - 18:43

SOURCE: American Heritage (12-1-06)

As an American President presides over a divisive war without an apparent end, for the second time in my life, my thoughts have been drawn back nearly four decades to another President, Lyndon Baines Johnson, and his war in Vietnam. In 1969 a strange twist of history—his and mine—made me, by then an antiwar activist, the publisher of a retired President whom I both respected and hated.

Although I had seen the polls indicating that a substantial majority of the public had lost confidence in Johnson’s conduct of the war, I was nevertheless shocked when, in March 1968, he announced that instead of running for another term as president of the United States he would retire and return to his home in the Texas Hill Country.

I had once admired him as the man who had pushed through the legislation that for the first time since Reconstruction enabled all eligible African-Americans to vote. I respected him as the leader whose Medicare legislation fulfilled the early...

Friday, December 8, 2006 - 18:41

SOURCE: International Herald Tribune (12-6-06)

What is the defining line between a civilized and uncivilized country? In my own experience in Turkey since Nov. 19, it is freedom of expression: I have been accused of treason in the press and suspended from my university for defending the common values of civilization and re-evaluating Turkey's history.

I am an academic, a university professor, studying politics, political philosophy and political economy. On Nov. 18, I spoke on a panel in the western coastal city of Izmir organized by the local branch of the governing Justice and Development Party (AKP).

I explained a definition I call the "common civilization paradigm": it requires private property, free exchange, limited and responsible accountable government, freedom of expression, religious freedom including minorities and non-believers, the absence of political crimes in law, political opposition, the rule of law and freedom of association, leading to horizontal instead of vertical leadership...

Thursday, December 7, 2006 - 23:13

SOURCE: NYT (12-7-06)

Here, 64 years late, are edited excerpts from a dispatch sent to The New York Times by Robert Trumbull, the paper’s correspondent at Pearl Harbor. It details a triumphant but mostly forgotten story of World War II: the salvage effort that rebuilt the Pacific Fleet after the Japanese attack.

A city of seamen, engineers, divers, carpenters, welders, pipe fitters and other industrial workers arose overnight at the Pearl Harbor Navy Yard. Its slogan was “We keep them fit to fight,” and within two years the yard raised or salvaged all the damaged ships except the Arizona and the Utah.

One year after the attack, with the harbor still choked with wreckage, Trumbull wrote a 15,000-word, three-part series about the round-the-clock operation. But wartime censorship killed the articles. Like the civilian rescue workers and hardhats at ground zero, the shipyard workers dispersed, unheralded, when the job was done. Trumbull died in 1992.

PEARL HARBOR, Dec. 13 (...

Thursday, December 7, 2006 - 16:52

SOURCE: WSJ (12-6-06)

[Mr. Siegel is professor of finance at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.]

Ten years ago yesterday, Alan Greenspan made what was to become the most famous speech in his 18-year tenure as chairman of the Federal Reserve. Against a backdrop of a strong economy and soaring stock market, Mr. Greenspan said: "How do we know when irrational exuberance has unduly escalated asset values? . . . We should not underestimate . . . the interactions of asset markets and the economy. Asset prices, particularly, must be an integral part of the development of monetary policy."

Stocks indeed were surging when Mr. Greenspan spoke at the annual dinner of the American Enterprise Institute in Washington. The Dow Jones Industrial Average had crossed 5000 in November 1995 and 6000 in October 1996. On the day of Mr. Greenspan's speech, the Dow industrials stood at 6437, more than twice the level it reached only four years earlier. Many economists claimed that...

Wednesday, December 6, 2006 - 21:02

SOURCE: Chronicle of Higher Education (12-8-06)

[Russell Jacoby is a professor in residence in the history department at the University of California at Los Angeles. He is the author, most recently, of Picture Imperfect: Utopian Thought for an Anti-Utopian Age (Columbia University Press, 2005).]

A street is named after her. Back-to-back conferences celebrate her. New books champion her. Hannah Arendt, who was born 100 years ago this past October, has joined the small world of philosophical heroes. Nor has this attention come to her only since her death in 1975. During her life, she received honorary degrees from Princeton, Smith, and other colleges and universities. Denmark awarded her its Sonning Prize for "commendable work that benefits European culture," also bestowed on Albert Schweitzer and Winston Churchill. When she gave public lectures, students jammed the aisles and doorways.

Arendt fits the bill for a philosophical hero. She was a German Jewish refugee drenched in classical education and...

Tuesday, December 5, 2006 - 20:52

SOURCE: Salon (12-5-06)

Who said this, and when?

Our civilization rests upon a technological base which requires enormous quantities of fossil fuels. What assurance do we then have that our energy needs will continue to be supplied by fossil fuels: The answer is -- in the long run -- none.

In the face of the basic fact that fossil fuel reserves are finite, the exact length of time these reserves will last is important in only one respect: the longer they last, the more time do we have, to invent ways of living off renewable or substitute energy sources and to adjust our economy to the vast changes which we can expect from such a shift.

Fossil fuels resemble capital in the bank. A prudent and responsible parent will use his capital sparingly in order to pass on to his children as much as possible of his inheritance. A selfish and irresponsible parent will squander it in riotous living and care not one whit how his offspring will fare.

For more than...

Tuesday, December 5, 2006 - 20:31

SOURCE: WaPo (12-3-06)

... To qualify a president for the Worst of All Time list, a war must be catastrophic as well as unnecessary. Ronald Reagan's invasion of Grenada, George H.W. Bush's invasion of Panama and Bill Clinton's invasion of Haiti don't cut it -- they were unnecessary, but minor. And presidents can be forgiven costly wars that were necessary or hard to avoid, such as Harry S. Truman's stalemated war in Korea and Lyndon B. Johnson's failed war in Vietnam, each of which was a Cold War battle more than a separate conflict. After 1950, U.S. strategy required Washington to go to war to prevent Soviet bloc proxies from taking over South Korea, Indochina and Taiwan -- the amazing thing is that the Cold War ended without a battle for Taiwan, too. Future historians are likely to be as kind to LBJ as they have been to Truman.

The two big, unjustified wars on my list are the War of 1812 and the current conflict in Iraq, and the first was far worse than the second. Madison, the "Father of...

Tuesday, December 5, 2006 - 19:43

SOURCE: British Archaeology (10-1-06)

[Roger Matthews was the last resident director of the British School of Archaeology in Iraq, living in Baghdad until 1990, and is currently professor of Near Eastern archaeology at ucl Institute of Archaeology. Michael Seymour is a specialist in the history and politics of archaeology in the Middle East. He recently completed a doctorate at UCL Institute of Archaeology, and is now Raymond and Beverley Sackler scholar in ancient Iranian studies at the British Museum for 2006–7.]

In April 2003, as American tanks entered the streets of Baghdad, local resentment against the regime of Saddam Hussein manifested itself in a wave of looting, asset-stripping and burning of government and official buildings across Iraq's capital city. Cultural facilities such as universities, libraries, art galleries and museums were not excluded from the destruction and uncontrolled appropriation that affected government ministries, official residences and elite palaces. The looting of the globally...

Monday, December 4, 2006 - 21:48

SOURCE: New Republic (12-1-06)

[Andrew Delbanco is director of American Studies at Columbia University. His most recent book, Melville: His World and Work, has just been published in paperback by Vintage.]

It's a peculiarity of academic life that, every fall, I find myself a year older facing students who somehow remain the same age. This poses a problem for anyone who takes seriously John Dewey's dictum that "knowledge of the past and its heritage is of great significance when it enters into the present, but not otherwise." It's a problem because, with each passing year, I know less about the present in which the students live. I rarely venture into the blogosphere or get through a graphic novel. I know nothing about the music they listen to and not much about how they organize their private lives. So I decided last spring to teach a class on a subject that I figured might bring us together over a matter of common urgency. The subject was war.
For many in my generation (I'm pushing...

Sunday, December 3, 2006 - 21:52

SOURCE: WaPo (12-3-06)

[Eric Foner is DeWitt Clinton professor of history at Columbia University.]

Ever since 1948, when Harvard professor Arthur Schlesinger Sr. asked 55 historians to rank U.S. presidents on a scale from "great" to "failure," such polls have been a favorite pastime for those of us who study the American past.

Changes in presidential rankings reflect shifts in how we view history. When the first poll was taken, the Reconstruction era that followed the Civil War was regarded as a time of corruption and misgovernment caused by granting black men the right to vote. As a result, President Andrew Johnson, a fervent white supremacist who opposed efforts to extend basic rights to former slaves, was rated "near great." Today, by contrast, scholars consider Reconstruction a flawed but noble attempt to build an interracial democracy from the ashes of slavery -- and Johnson a flat failure.

More often, however, the rankings display a...

Sunday, December 3, 2006 - 21:16

SOURCE: WaPo (12-3-06)

[David Greenberg teaches history and media studies at Rutgers University.]

In 1950, President Harry S. Truman was under fire for "losing" China to communist forces, engaging in deficit spending and seeking to expand unemployment insurance. Harold E. Stassen, a prominent Republican, blasted him as "the worst president ever to occupy the White House."

Four years later, under Dwight D. Eisenhower, job growth had slowed and wages were down. West Virginia Sen. Matthew M. Neely declared Ike "the worst president in United States history."

In 1973, as Richard M. Nixon foundered amid the worsening Watergate scandal, crippling stagflation and increasing social strife, labor leader George Meany asserted, "He will go down in history as one of our worst presidents."

Six years into Ronald Reagan's presidency, the Iran-contra scandal broke and his approval ratings fell into the 40s. Ted Sorensen, who was a speechwriter...


Sunday, December 3, 2006 - 21:16