George Mason University's
History News Network

Roundup: Talking About History


This is where we excerpt articles about history that appear in the media. Among the subjects included on this page are: anniversaries of historical events, legacies of presidents, cutting-edge research, and historical disputes.

SOURCE: Japan Focus (2-14-06)

[Many older Japanese conservatives are deeply committed to pacifism as a result of their personal experiences in World War II, despite recent Japanese government efforts to assert the right to belligerence in the present and the legitimacy of Japan’s wars in the 1930s and 1940s. Nonaka Hiromu, the former Secretary-General of the Liberal Democratic Party, retired from politics last year. But he still openly criticizes Prime Minister Koizumi’s visits to Yasukuni Shrine, his foreign policy, and the LDP's planned revision of Japan’s Constitution. He lost his cousin and uncle in the Asia-Pacific War. Gotoda Masaharu, who served as Chief Cabinet Secretary for the Nakasone Cabinet in the 1980s and was also highly critical of both Koizumi’s foreign and domestic policies, died last year. He was also as a staunch supporter of Article 9, the “no-war clause,” of Japan’s Constitution. Watanabe Tsuneo, the Editorial...

Thursday, February 16, 2006 - 20:12

SOURCE: Frontpagemag.com (2-13-06)

Victor Davis Hanson gave the following speech at the Wednesday Morning Club at the Four Seasons Hotel in Los Angeles, California, on February 1, 2006. For more information on the Wednesday Morning Club, e-mail Mike. --FrontPageMag Editors.

Michael Wiener: It’s truly an honor to be here to introduce to you somebody whom I greatly admire and whom I consider a friend. Victor Davis Hanson is a military historian and a classical scholar. He’s a Director Emeritus of Classics at California State University at Fresno. He’s a Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institute at Stanford and Fellow at the Center for Advanced Study of Behavioral Science, also at Stanford. He has won awards as a commentator. He has won awards as a journalist. He’s the National Endowment for the Humanities Fellow and the Manassas Fellow in Greece. He’s a terrific fellow, I might add. And he’s also been a professor at the United States Naval Academy in Annapolis. He’s written many...


Wednesday, February 15, 2006 - 22:51

SOURCE: Sandstorm (blog) (2-15-06)

As I've just reported, the National Research Council of the National Academies has commenced its $1.5 million review of Title VI, the federal subsidy program for language and area studies in universities. The first question members of the review committee should ask themselves is this: is Title VI doing the job Congress thinks it's doing?

Title VI has always been marketed to Congress as a language program, first and foremost. Students on Title VI fellowships, Congress is told, are gaining proficiency in difficult languages, while they study some history, political science, anthropology, and so on. The grand old man of Title VI, Richard Lambert, who did important evaluations of the program, once explained how he sold it:

Language competencies were always in the forefront of our public presentations. When we marched up the hill and testified [before Congress], we always argued that...

Wednesday, February 15, 2006 - 21:38

SOURCE: New Republic (2-14-06)

Abraham Lincoln's long limbs and saturnine features have lately been stretched out on the psychotherapist's couch. The cover to last October's Atlantic Monthly considered "Lincoln's Great Depression" (an excerpt from Joshua Wolf Shenk's book Lincoln's Melancholy). Applying modern clinical diagnoses to the historical record, Shenk found him to be a severe manic depressive with suicidal tendencies. Peeking into his medicine cabinet, he noted a pharmacopeia of opiates, sarsaparilla, cocaine, and mercury pills. Last month, a lavishly promoted three-hour film on the History Channel (seen by some 2.8 million households) pressed the case further, dwelling on Lincoln's premonitions of his own death, his inferiority complex, and his likely--at least in Gore Vidal's view--homosexuality.

It is into this thicket of psychobabble that John Ford's Young Mr. Lincoln strides--long-legged, loose-limbed, and a hundred feet tall. The 1939 film is being issued for the first time on...

Tuesday, February 14, 2006 - 21:24

SOURCE: Harper's (2-13-06)

Every time I take my kids to the Tecumseh Playground, at 77th Street and Amsterdam Avenue, in Manhattan, I'm troubled by a political paradox.

On the one hand, this Western-themed lot for tots means to honor Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman, of Confederacy-destroying and Indian-killing fame, as does the adjacent public school, which bears his full name. A placard at the playground entrance also touts Sherman's tour as a New Yorker, since the scourge of Atlanta and the Carolinas spent his theatergoing retirement in Gotham, living out his days on West 71st Street not far from Broadway.

On the other hand, my local playground serves one of the most anti-war constituencies in America, the Upper West Side. Until the word liberal was banned from public discourse, most Upper West Siders militantly identified themselves as liberal—indeed, their steadfast support for peacenik politicians, from Adlai Stevenson to George McGovern to Howard Dean, is legendary. If New York...

Tuesday, February 14, 2006 - 21:05

SOURCE: NY Sun (2-14-06)

[Mr. Radosh, adjunct senior fellow at the Hudson Institute, is co-author with Joyce Milton of "The Rosenberg File."]

Everyone loves conspiracy theories, and Europe is no different. First they had the best-selling French book whose author claimed the September 11 attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon were covert actions of American intelligence; next there was the Arab world's claim that it was an operation by Israeli intelligence. Now we have a new one - in the form of a much-hyped German television documentary, "Rendezvous With Death," directed by Wilfried Huismann with the help of an American JFK assassination buff named Gus Russo. The film first aired in Germany in January and is now being readied for American distribution.

Ulrich Deppendorf, the director of German television's public broadcasting network, ARD - the equivalent of PBS here - claims the documentary proves that "Lee Harvey Oswald was the final pawn in a...

Tuesday, February 14, 2006 - 20:18

SOURCE: Chronicle of Higher Education (2-13-06)

[Mark M. Smith is a professor of history at the University of South Carolina and editor of Stono: Documenting and Interpreting a Southern Slave Revolt (University of South Carolina Press, 2005). This excerpt is from How Race Is Made: Slavery, Segregation, and the Senses, published this month by the University of North Carolina Press.]

... modern discussions of race and racial identity are hostage to the eye. With few exceptions, popular writing as well as many academic works — even the most theoretically sophisticated ones — tend to treat race as an exclusively visual phenomenon, so much so that the panacea for modern ills is, by some lights, a colorblind society. Even though we know that race is a construct, an invented category that defies scientific verification, we still understand that construction as a largely visual enterprise. "Color" is always seen. But the preference for "seeing" race is as much a social construction as "race" itself...

Monday, February 13, 2006 - 23:44

SOURCE: NYT (12-31-69)

MRS. Sandoval," Homer Macauley said, "your son is dead. Maybe it's a mistake. Maybe it wasn't your son. Maybe it was somebody else. The telegram says it was Juan Domingo. But maybe the telegram is wrong."

Beginning in the mid-19th century, the telegram was the most immediate way of distributing news or sending a message. Whether it was one of those dreaded "regret to inform you" notices from the War Department that William Saroyan's Homer delivered in "The Human Comedy," or "send money" pleas or birthday congratulations, the arrival by hand of those yellow envelopes always seemed momentous. In that spirit, the evangelist Billy Graham was quoted as saying, "I am only a Western Union messenger boy, delivering a telegram from God to the door of humanity."

In 1929, Western Union and its army of uniformed messengers sent more than 200 million telegrams. By last year, that number had dwindled to 21,000. Bowing...

Sunday, February 12, 2006 - 14:25

SOURCE: NYT (12-31-69)

When Noah Webster published "A Compendious Dictionary of the English Language," purists were horrified. Webster Americanized the British spellings in Samuel Johnson's famous dictionary, turning "defence" and "honour" into "defense" and "honor," and dropping the "k" from "musick." Webster included new American words like "subsidize" and "caucus," and left out hoary Britishisms like "fishefy." John Quincy Adams, the future president, was shocked by the "local vulgarisms," and doubted that Harvard, of which he was a trustee, would ever endorse such a radical "departure from the English language."

Webster's "Compendious Dictionary," which was published 200 years ago this month, defied the skeptics to become a success, and it was the forerunner to his much larger, and classic, 1828 "American Dictionary of the English Language." Webster is...

Sunday, February 12, 2006 - 14:15

SOURCE: Baltimore Sun (2-12-06)

[Mr. Hill is a staff reporter for the Baltimore Sun.]

Most say that America today is a distressingly polarized country - deeply divided over issues from abortion to gun control, from affirmative action to evolution.

Hah! You want polarized? Think of the country that Abraham Lincoln faced when he took office in 1861 - states seceding, a Civil War on the horizon, all over the seemingly insoluble issue of slavery, the one that had stumped the founding fathers.

Or, for that matter, think of the country when Lincoln began his second term in 1865 with only a few weeks to live. A victorious North was trying to figure out what to do with a defeated South and millions of newly freed slaves - with opinions ranging from forgive and forget to ruthless revenge.

One big difference between now and then is that then the president was Lincoln. That is no disrespect to the current occupant of the Oval Office. Few, if any, who have held that office live...

Sunday, February 12, 2006 - 12:21

The legacy of the baby-boom generation may not be as great as some boomers like to believe it is, says Gary Kamiya, executive editor of the online magazine.

This he writes in response to the new book The Greater Generation (St. Martin's Press, 2006), by Leonard Steinhorn, an associate professor of communication at American University. In the book, Mr. Steinhorn argues that even though it was the boomers' parents -- often referred to as "the greatest generation" -- who dragged the nation out of the Great Depression and helped win World War II, it was their children who ultimately achieved a better society.

Mr. Steinhorn touts the narrowing of the racial divide as one of the boomers' many great achievements. While Mr. Kamiya, a boomer himself, acknowledges that the United States is far less racist than it was in the 1950s, he reminds readers that there is still a division: "America continues to be profoundly segregated, and people of color are...

Tuesday, February 7, 2006 - 23:05

[Noliwe M. Rooks is associate director of the program in African American studies at Princeton University. Her book White Money/Black Power: The Surprising History of African American Studies and the Crisis of Race in Higher Education has just been published by Beacon Press.]

In the late 1960s, black studies became a part of American higher education. By 1971 more than 500 programs, departments, and institutes had been founded on four-year college campuses; add in black-studies initiatives in those same years at high schools and community colleges, and the number jumps to more than 1,000. Today roughly 450 colleges and universities offer graduate programs, undergraduate programs, or both. To be sure, those numbers represent an occasion to celebrate. But jubilance may be premature. It is becoming increasingly clear that before the field can move confidently into the future we need to clear up some continuing confusion about why and how what we now call African-American...

Tuesday, February 7, 2006 - 23:00

SOURCE: Common Dreams (2-7-06)

[Robert Jensen is a journalism professor at the University of Texas at Austin and a member of the board of the Third Coast Activist Resource Center. He is the author of "The Heart of Whiteness: Race, Racism, and White Privilege" and "Citizens of the Empire: The Struggle to Claim Our Humanity" (both from City Lights Books). Email to: rjensen@uts.cc.utexas.edu]

In an “urgent” email last week, right-wing activist David Horowitz hyped his latest book about threats to America’s youth from leftist professors.

The ad for “The Professors -- The 101 Most Dangerous Academics in America” describes me as: “Texas Journalism Professor Robert Jensen, who rabidly hates the United States, and recently told his students, ‘The United States has lost the war in Iraq and that’s a good thing.’”

I’m glad Horowitz got my name right (people often misspell it “Jenson”). But everything else is distortion,...

Tuesday, February 7, 2006 - 22:44

SOURCE: Boston Globe (2-6-06)

America has had a difficult time reckoning with its racist past. Slavery was a defining part of the cultures and economies out of which the nation grew, and for most of its first century the ownership of humans by other humans was taken for granted. A pseudo-Darwinian ranking by ''race" justified that order, which stood on pillars of skin color and ethnic origin. When that blatant structure of denigration was overthrown by the Civil War, implicit assumptions of white supremacy remained so lodged in the national psyche that slavery became a half remembered shadow, with heirs of slave-holders in contented denial about its brutality and descendants of slaves locked in punishing marginality by means of legal insult and economic short shrift.
Failure to reckon with slavery and its consequences is still the American problem, which is manifest not only by the unyielding grip of white racism that impossibly burdens one generation of African-Americans after another, but also in the...

Monday, February 6, 2006 - 21:03

SOURCE: Weekly Standard (2-6-06)

[Arnold Beichman is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University.]

THERE IS NOTHING SADDER--for me anyway--than watching a newspaper or magazine go under, as has just happened to the New Leader, for which I used to write.

I go back far enough to recall the shutdown in 1931 of the New York World, the Pulitzer flagship, which Pulitzer's sons sold to the New York Evening Telegram. I was working my way through Columbia College as a night copyboy at the New York Herald Tribune on West 41st Street. My last assignment of the night was to deliver late syndicated copy (this was the Stone Age, no fax machines) to a Buffalo Courier-Express correspondent in the old World Building on Park Row across the street from City Hall.

My boyhood ambition was to be a reporter on the World, a daily with a unique distinction. Its city editor, Charles Chapin, was convicted on January 14, 1919, for the murder of his wife. But the paper had other...

Monday, February 6, 2006 - 17:47

SOURCE: News of Delaware County (2-8-06)

[Jim Castagnera is a Philadelphia attorney and author, who writes a weekly newspaper column, “Attorney at Large.”]

Pennsylvania lawmakers are worried that our kids in college are being brainwashed.

Late last month a committee of the Pennsylvania state legislature convened in Philadelphia to investigate whether the Commonwealth’s colleges discriminate against politically conservative students. The committee took two days of testimony at Temple University. Established last July, this committee will conduct two more hearings in other parts of the state, before reporting back to the House of Representatives next November.

Representative Gibson C. Armstrong, a Republican out of Lancaster County, introduced the resolution creating the committee. During the first day of the hearings, Armstrong told Temple President David Adamany he had received more than a dozen complaints from Owl students about political indoctrination in the classroom. While defending his faculty...


Monday, February 6, 2006 - 01:08

SOURCE: Cliopatria Blog on HNN (2-2-06)

The young Tadeusz (or Thaddeus) Andrzej Bonawentura Kosciuszko (pronounced KOS-CHOOS-KO, 2/4/1746-10/15/1817), born near Brest (now in Belarus) studied military engineering in Paris with the intent of serving in his native Poland. However, in 1772 Prussia, Austria and Russia had partitioned Poland, seizing around 30% of its territory and forcing governmental changes through bribes, threats and arrests. There was no place in the Polish Army for Kosciuszko, and he left in 1775 to France where, at some point in late 1775, he heard about the American rebellion against the British and was recruited by Silas Deane and Benjamin Franklin.

Like many young Europeans of his time, he was enthralled with the Revolutionary activity in the New World. Shortly after arriving in Philadelphia in 1776, Kosciuszko read the Declaration of Independence and he recognized everything in which he truly believed. When he discovered Thomas Jefferson was responsible for drafting the Declaration, he had to...


Friday, February 3, 2006 - 20:14

SOURCE: WSJ (12-27-05)

In "The Conservative Mind" (1953), a founding document of the American conservative movement, Russell Kirk assembled an array of major thinkers beginning with Edmund Burke and made a major statement. He proved that conservative thought in America existed, and even that such thought was highly intelligent--a demonstration very much needed at the time.

Today we are in a very different and more complicated situation. Nevertheless, a synthesis is possible, based on what American conservatism has achieved and left unachieved since Kirk's volume. Any political position is only as important as the thought by which it is derived; the political philosopher presiding will be Burke, but a Burke interpreted for a new constitutional republic and for modern life. Here, then, is my assessment of the ideas held in balance in the American Conservative Mind today.

Hard utopianism. During the 20th century, socialism and communism tried to effect versions of their...

Friday, February 3, 2006 - 18:56

SOURCE: Editor & PUblisher (1-30-06`)

A recent Los Angeles Times article, and then a widely-published Jonah Goldberg column, questioned the character of Upton Sinclair, based on the discovery of a 1929 letter about the Sacco and Vanzetti case. One problem: Some facts were overlooked or wrong.

This is the story of a recent Los Angeles Times “scoop” that was error-ridden and misleading and resulted in a hysterical rightwing attack, led by Jonah Goldberg, on a famed author nearly 40 years after his passing.

It all began a little over a month ago, on Dec. 24, with an article in the metro section of the L.A. Times by Orange County reporter Jean O. Pasco, headlined, “Sinclair Letter Turns Out to be Another Expose.” It revealed that a Newport Beach attorney named Paul Hegness had finally gotten around to exploring the contents of a box of dusty old papers sitting in a closet that he had purchased at an Irvine auction for $100.

A letter postmarked Sept. 12, 1929, caught his eye. It was...

Friday, February 3, 2006 - 18:25

SOURCE: Legal Times (1-30-06)

The recent nomination of Judge Samuel Alito Jr. to the Supreme Court unearthed yet another reminder of the continuing influence of the politics of the 1960s counterculture on our current legal and political culture. After Alito arrived at Yale Law School in the fall of 1972, he hoped that he would take his first-year constitutional law class from Professor Robert Bork, according to The Washington Post.

Instead, Alito’s constitutional law professor turned out to be Charles Reich, a liberal law professor who had become a celebrity after his book, The Greening of America, became a best seller after its publication in 1970.

Alito appears headed to the Supreme Court. What happened to his professor? At the time Reich was Alito’s professor, he still was widely known as a result of The Greening. The book was an unusual combination of sociology (in Reich’s analysis of “consciousness,” how people thought about their lives and work) and manifesto (in his embrace of the student...


Thursday, February 2, 2006 - 19:35