George Mason University's
History News Network

Roundup: Talking About History


This is where we excerpt articles about history that appear in the media. Among the subjects included on this page are: anniversaries of historical events, legacies of presidents, cutting-edge research, and historical disputes.

SOURCE: The Scotsman (11-30-05)

The majority of Scots are likely to go about their business today without a thought for the significance of the date, and without any plans to note either its arrival or passing.
...
There are signs Scotland is slowly waking up to the benefits of celebrating St Andrew, if not with an official holiday, then with cultural and social festivities which set the day apart from any other.
...
So this year, the Executive hosts festivities in Edinburgh for the first time: a One Scotland Ceilidh playing at an open air stage and an indoor venue in the capital.

And across the world the Executive is supporting 41 St Andrew's Day events, with celebrations taking place as far afield as Australia, the US, Russia and Japan.

The First Minister, Jack McConnell, yesterday circulated a St Andrew's Day message to embassies and consulates around the world raising awareness of what he said were Scotland's achievements.

But academics, politicians and...

Wednesday, November 30, 2005 - 13:03

SOURCE: Newsday (11-30-05)

Earlier this month, a federal judge granted the Shinnecock Indians one of their biggest victories since English settlers arrived in Southampton four centuries ago - in a rare decision, U.S. District Court Judge Thomas Platt decided the Shinnecocks were a bona fide Indian tribe. In the weeks since Platt's ruling, Newsday has examined the hundreds of documents that make up the tribe's application for federal recognition to the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs, which is pending.
...
The history of Southampton's Shinnecock Indians sits in two cardboard boxes in a back office of the U.S. Department of the Interior in Washington, D.C.

Hundreds of dramatic moments are distilled there on letter-sized copy paper: Notes from contentious trustee meetings dating to the Revolutionary War; a 19th-century pastor's handwritten history of his Shinnecock parish; a genealogical tree tracing tribe members' births, deaths and marriages back to 1800.

Long Island's first...

Wednesday, November 30, 2005 - 12:56

SOURCE: The Guardian (London) (11-30-05)

One of the more convenient side-effects of the explosion of interest in family history is that you need never again be stumped for what to give your nearest and dearest for Christmas. Instead of a lacklustre pair of socks or bottle of whisky, what could be more thrilling than a voucher that entitles the grateful recipient to extended access to the online version of the 1901 census?

For we are all historians now, chroniclers not so much of big events like the 1832 reform bill but of what year Auntie Joan went into service, or why Great-Grandfather Billy had to marry only five months before his eldest was born. Our heads are full not of kings and queens but of the housemaids, grocers and sheep stealers whose shreds of DNA make up who we feel ourselves to be today.

You see this new breed of historian every time you enter a local record office on the outskirts of a county town: hunched over microfiche, pencil in hand (Biros count as lethal weapons), in search of...

Wednesday, November 30, 2005 - 12:49

SOURCE: The Daily Telegraph (LONDON) (11-30-05)

The bicentenary of the battle of Austerlitz, Napoleon's greatest victory, is to be shunned by France's two leading politicians.

Their absence comes amid an escalating row over whether to fete the emperor as a great leader or denounce him as a dictator.

Neither President Jacques Chirac nor his prime minister, Dominique de Villepin - an ardent admirer of Napoleon - will take part in the official ceremonies to mark the French army's defeat of Austrian and Russian forces on Dec 2, 1805.

Historians classify the battle of Austerlitz, now a town called Slavkov in the Czech Republic, as a military masterpiece, in which the 71,000 men of Napoleon's Grande Armée routed their 91,000 adversaries in just six hours, killing 19,000. The victory ended a coalition between Austria and Russia.

Low-key celebrations will take place on Friday in the Place Vendôme in central Paris and at the site of the battle, in the presence of the defence minister, Michèle...

Wednesday, November 30, 2005 - 12:48

SOURCE: WSJ (11-25-05)

The textbooks don't explain why the Pilgrims had only a meager harvest in 1621, so we will. For their first two years in Plymouth, the settlers conducted an experiment in communalism. It wasn't until 1623 that they divided the land into private plots and could look forward to the kind of bounty that many of us enjoyed yesterday. In his "History of Plimoth Plantation," the colony's governor, William Bradford, wrote about how the settlers studied human nature and laid the foundation for true Thanksgiving:

All this while no supply was heard of, neither knew they when they might expect any. So they began to think how they might raise as much corn as they could, and obtain a better crop than they had done, that they might not still thus languish in misery.

At length, after much debate of things, the Governor (with the advice of the chiefest amongst them) gave way that they should set corn every man for his own particular.... And so assigned to every family...

Tuesday, November 29, 2005 - 22:13

SOURCE: The Columbus Dispatch (11-29-05)

By all measures, E=mcc is the most famous equation in history, and its author, Albert Einstein, the most famous scientist.

It turns out, according to Frank Wilczek, who was awarded the Nobel Prize for physics in 2004, that Einstein originally wrote the equation as m=E/cc, in which E stands for energy, m for mass and cc for the speed of light squared.

As any seventh-grader knows, the equation works either way. But Einstein was interested in matter, so his first stab at it concentrated on the m.

Writing the equation for energy, however, provides a more cataclysmic insight into nature.

"E=mcc famously leads to the idea of getting huge amounts of energy out of a small amount of matter," Wilczek, an MIT physics professor, recently told an audience of scientists, Einstein buffs and Case Western Reserve University students in a packed hall in Cleveland.

Wilczek and a group of others were there to honor Einstein and his...

Tuesday, November 29, 2005 - 18:38

SOURCE: Chronicle of Higher Education (11-28-05)

[Rodney Stark is university professor of the social sciences at Baylor University. This essay is adapted from The Victory of Reason: How Christianity Led to Freedom, Capitalism, and Western Success, to be published in December by Random House.]

When Europeans first began to explore the globe, their greatest surprise was not the existence of the Western Hemisphere, but the extent of their own technological superiority over the rest of the world. Not only were the proud Maya, Aztec, and Inca nations helpless in the face of European intruders, so were the fabled civilizations of the East: China, India, and Islamic nations were "backward" by comparison with 15th-century Europe. How had that happened? Why was it that, although many civilizations had pursued alchemy, the study led to chemistry only in Europe? Why was it that, for centuries, Europeans were the only ones possessed of eyeglasses, chimneys, reliable clocks, heavy cavalry, or a system of music notation?...

Monday, November 28, 2005 - 22:42

SOURCE: Nation (11-22-05)

Rum has always tended to favor and flavor rebellion, from the pirates and buccaneers of the seventeenth century to the American Revolution onward. In addition, sugar and rum pretty much introduced globalization to a waiting world, tying together Europe, the Americas, Africa and the Caribbean in a complex alcoholic web of trade and credit. Not until oil was any single commodity so important for world trade. So it is not surprising that the Bacardi Corporation has become one of the world's first transnationals.

Even before Fidel Castro took power, the Bacardi family moved its headquarters from its Cuban home to the Bahamas, allowing it to get British imperial trade preferences, while opening a large distillery in Puerto Rico to allow penetration of the American market. Now its management is mostly living in exile in Florida, monopolizing the local markets across the Caribbean and the world with its bland, branded spirit. Fifty years of marketing have made Bacardi almost...

Monday, November 28, 2005 - 21:12

SOURCE: Newsday (New York) (11-28-05)

Eighty-five years ago, allegations that a black man had tried to assault a white woman in a city elevator spurred hundreds of whites to attack what was one of the country's most prosperous black communities, a bustling neighborhood called Greenwood.

Wess Young was only 3, but he still remembers his mother rousing him from bed in the middle of the night, and the gunshots crackling like fireworks as they ran through the burning streets to escape the riot. Otis Clark, who was 18, recalls blood spraying across him when a friend was shot in the hand as they tried to flee in an ambulance from a local funeral home.

Today, the two are among fewer than 100 known survivors of the May 31-June 1, 1921 riot, for which no one was punished and no reparations ever paid, despite the loss of hundreds of lives, businesses and fortunes. With survivors dying off, activists are hoping to change that, spurred not only by the injustice done to riot victims, but also by the plight of...

Monday, November 28, 2005 - 13:05

SOURCE: Wa Po (11-27-05)

The assassination of President John F. Kennedy remains the great unsolved mystery of American politics. With dozens of books in print on the subject, the case of the murdered commander in chief now seems to attract more interest from the publishing industry than from journalists or historians.

The fascination with a shocking crime is not hard to understand. On Nov. 22, 1963, the president was shot in the head during a motorcade through Dallas. Police arrested an ex-Marine named Lee Harvey Oswald, who proclaimed himself a "patsy." Two days later, a Dallas strip-club owner, Jack Ruby, shot Oswald dead on national TV. Not until the morning of Sept. 11, 2001, would the American people experience such a bewildering, sudden and painful loss.

Why official Washington has seemingly lost interest in the story in recent years is harder, though not impossible, to figure out. The JFK story remains an enduring symbol of popular mistrust. Public confidence in the...

Sunday, November 27, 2005 - 21:42

SOURCE: Wa Po (11-27-05)

One of the oddities of conventional biography is that when the subject is a person of great influence and renown, his or her private life is scanted at best, ignored at worst. We know, for example, that Franklin D. Roosevelt's mother was overbearing and dominating and that he was unhappy in prep school and college, but these crucial aspects of youth usually are noted by his biographers and then passed over, so that the march of great events -- the Depression, the 1932 election, the New Deal, court-packing, World War II -- can be given full-dress treatment. Even the polio that Roosevelt suffered in 1921, when he was 39, goes little mentioned once its onset and treatment have been discussed and analyzed.

This is in strange contrast to biographies of writers, artists, movie stars and others of "creative" bent, whose most intimate secrets are explored, often with obvious relish, either in the hope that they can explain the sources of the subjects' art or for gossip...

Sunday, November 27, 2005 - 21:40

SOURCE: Email to HNN (11-28-05)

[Ms. Murray is UFT Chapter Leader, P.S. 75, Bronx, NY 10459.]

Slavery is by no means a new phenomena. Therefore, it should not be used synonymously with the word African in America. Slavery is older than the Bible. The Israelites were enslaved in Egypt. It is not anomily that people throughout history have sunk again and again to the bowels of the earth to demonstate the worst case scenario of man's inhumanity to man: the enslavement of another. Lest we not forget Adolf Hitler. And if each one would objectivly research his/her ancestral past, he would find the remnants of slavery buried with the other societal skeletons. The difference maybe that Slavery in the United States was institutionalized and race was the issue. Although there has been blatant discrimination by religion and place of origin in America, race has always mattered when enslaving persons of color (Native Americans as well as Africans).

Although the exhibition at the New York Historical...


Sunday, November 27, 2005 - 21:02

SOURCE: Japan Focus (11-25-05)

[Yuki Tanaka, Hiroshima Peace Institute, is a Japan Focus Coordinator and author of Hidden Horrors. Japanese War Crimes in World War II.]

It is widely believed that the major source of kamikaze suicide pilots was the Air Force Cadet Officer System in the Japanese Imperial Navy and Army Forces, which recruited university and college students on a voluntary basis. In fact, however, the majority of kamikaze pilots were young noncommissioned or petty officers, that is graduates of Navy and Army junior flight training schools. A total of 708 noncommissioned Army officers died as kamikaze pilots, while the total death toll of Army Air Force officer class kamikaze pilots was 621. In the Navy, 1732 petty officers died as kamikaze pilots compared with 782 officers. Many assume that the majority of kamikaze pilots were former college students, because the letters-home, diaries and wills of these young men, who became kamikaze pilots through the Air Force Cadet Officer System, were...

Sunday, November 27, 2005 - 16:29

Every three years, the Middle East Studies Association (MESA) brings its annual conference to Washington, presumably to impress upon lawmakers the relevance of Middle Eastern studies. The conference is meeting in a Washington hotel right now. So it's an appropriate moment to consider how the field's priorities have shifted since 9/11 and the Iraq war.

One measurable indicator is the papers presented at the annual conference. In the four MESA conferences since 9/11 (2002 through this year), some 1,900 papers have appeared in the program. That's a substantial sample of what interests people. But it's more than a measure of pure intellectual interest. Like all such meetings, MESA is a place where grad students and untenured faculty display their wares, in the hope of attracting job offers. It's also where the mandarins send signals to their...

Friday, November 25, 2005 - 19:50

SOURCE: Boston Globe (11-25-05)

[Harvey A. Silverglate is of counsel to the law firm of Good & Cormier. Norman S. Zalkind is a member of Zalkind, Rodriguez, Lunt & Duncan.]

A FEDERAL lawsuit we recently filed seeks to reaffirm a guiding American legal principle endangered by the ''culture wars," namely the right to an unrestrained mind, free of censorship and state orthodoxies.

Centered broadly on competing historical interpretations of a century-old conflict but, more precisely, on technical evaluations of a recently enacted Massachusetts statute, our lawsuit challenges the Massachusetts Department of Education's attempt to stamp its imprimatur on a single view of history, to the exclusion of all others, on the minds of our high school students.

The plaintiffs are two public school teachers, a high school senior, and the Assembly of Turkish American Associations. Though from different backgrounds and points of view, all the plaintiffs and lawyers in this...

Friday, November 25, 2005 - 18:47

SOURCE: New Republic (11-18-05)

The recent flood of admiring farewell tributes to Rosa Parks offers a sharp contrast to the generally gloomy tone of last year's fiftieth anniversary assessments of the significance of Brown v. Board of Education. In keeping with the prevailing tendency throughout the academy to emphasize the agency of the masses, over the last decade or so, many historians have made grassroots activism in the face of local hostility and national indifference the overriding theme of their interpretations of the Civil Rights movement. At the same time, other scholars and legal experts have questioned the overall importance of the Supreme Court in helping either to inspire the crusade for racial equality or to secure its overall goals. Taken together, these trends seem almost to suggest a historical view of the Civil Rights movement as less a collective than a competitive enterprise--where the significance of the "bottom-up" initiatives of Parks and others is pitted against the "top-down...

Friday, November 25, 2005 - 18:23

SOURCE: NYT (11-24-05)

[James E. McWilliams, a history professor at Texas State University at San Marcos, is the author of "A Revolution in Eating: How the Quest for Food Shaped America."]


...The native American food that the Pilgrims supposedly enjoyed would have offended the palate of any self-respecting English colonist - the colonial minister Charles Woodmason called it "exceedingly filthy and most execrable." Our comfort food, in short, was the bane of the settlers' culinary existence.

Understanding this paradox requires acknowledging that there's no evidence to support the holiday's early association with food - much less foods native to North America. Thanksgiving celebrations occurred irregularly at best after 1621 (the year of the supposed first Thanksgiving) and colonists observed them as strictly religious events (conceivably by fasting).

It wasn't until the mid-19th century that domestic writers began to play down Thanksgiving's...

Thursday, November 24, 2005 - 15:08

SOURCE: Spiegel (11-18-05)

Sixty years ago on Sunday, the Nuremberg War Crimes Trial got under way to bring leading Nazis to justice. Whitney Harris was one of the principle figures for the prosecution. SPIEGEL ONLINE spoke with him about Auschwitz commandant Rudolf Höss, the emotional scars left behind by the trial, and the United States of today.

Whitney Harris was the right-hand man of US Chief Prosecutor Robert Jackson during the Nuremberg Trials.SPIEGEL ONLINE: In 1945 when you began collecting evidence for the prosecution of Nazi war criminals, you had nothing more than a used typewriter, a German secretary and a lot of good will. Were you not overwhelmed by the huge responsibility of bringing charges against the former Nazi leaders?

Harris: The whole court case was a huge challenge. I was assigned to the case of Ernst Kaltenbrunner, meaning I had to investigate the murder of millions of Jews. Kaltenbrunner took over from Reinhard Heydrich as the head of Reich security and was in...

Wednesday, November 23, 2005 - 18:55

SOURCE: Japan Focus ()

Japan's Unit 731 remains central to the fiercely contested China-Japan controversy over war crimes and war memory, and to the international debate on science and ethics. With a staff of more than 10,000, including many of Japan’s top medical scientists, 731 and its affiliated units conducted human experiments, including vivisection, on Chinese and other victims in Manchukuo and throughout China between 1933 and 1945. The experiments tested, among other things, the lethality of biological weapons and sought to determine the ability of the human body to survive in the face of various pathogens and in conditions such as extreme cold.

Tsuneishi Keiichi is Japan's leading specialist on biowarfare. His voluminous studies conducted over thirty years in Japan, China, the United States and Europe, have provided core material for all writing hitherto on the Ishii Network. In the following careful resumé essay, he concentrates on organization and function, omitting much of the...

Wednesday, November 23, 2005 - 16:16

SOURCE: WSJ ()

Its mention of God makes it verboten in schools today. But not too many years ago this was the season when teachers would lead their students in the great ecumenical Thanksgiving hymn, "We Gather Together to Ask the Lord's Blessing." It's a singable melody, and the stirring lyrics speak directly of the Pilgrims' experience in overcoming religious persecution.

Or do they? With the exception of Native Americans, we're all the descendants of those who came to the New World from somewhere else. So too, it turns out, did "We Gather Together," whose origins are Dutch and speak of religious persecution that predates the first Thanksgiving. It's appropriate that a hymn we sing to celebrate a quintessentially American holiday is, like most of us, a transplant.

The melody can be traced back to 1597 and is probably older than that. It started out as a folk song, whose secular lyrics set a decidedly nonreligious tone. "Wilder dan wilt, wie sal mij...

Tuesday, November 22, 2005 - 18:25