George Mason University's
History News Network

Roundup: Talking About History


This is where we excerpt articles about history that appear in the media. Among the subjects included on this page are: anniversaries of historical events, legacies of presidents, cutting-edge research, and historical disputes.

SOURCE: The Straits Times (Singapore) (9-12-05)

The setting was grand. The Municipal Building looked out over the harbour, with '100,000 of the local population on the ground' - so wrote one Major-General Sir C. Lanes Letter.

Former prisoners of war packed the balconies of the building now known as City Hall, watching the defeated Japanese march in. Locals waited on the Padang for the ceremony, which would mark the end of three years of oppressive Japanese rule.

The same Union Jack that had been taken down on Feb 15, 1942 - when General Arthur Percival surrendered Singapore - was retrieved from its hiding place in Changi Prison, and flown proud and high again. It was an impressive, emotive spectacle - exactly what it was meant to be.
...
But a new page of history had turned, pointed out Associate Professor Kevin Blackburn, also with the NIE: 'People were meant to be impressed, but over 3 1/2 years, they saw their white masters doing the jobs of coolies.

'That an Asian country had...

Monday, September 12, 2005 - 17:43

SOURCE: Irish Times (8-30-05)

[Jim Duffy is a historian and political commentator.]

Ireland loves its history. But it likes one-sided history. The side may change, depending on each generation's fad, fashion or political correctness.

Take the early 20th century myth: how an oppressed Ireland rose up against its British oppressor in 1916. Not exactly. In reality only a tiny fringe rose. Far from having the country behind them, they needed protection from Dublin mobs, while nationalist newspapers called for the execution of Pearse, Connolly and the rest of the leaders.

Roll on a couple of years to the triumph of republicanism in the 1918 general election, and many of its critics jumped on the 1916 bandwagon, with far more claiming to have been in the GPO than physically would have fitted in the building. And yet, somehow Ireland was neither as anti-British nor as pro-Sinn Fein as the later spin suggested.

Throughout the 1920s Remembrance Sunday wreath-layings at the...

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 16:47

SOURCE: Gazette (Montreal) (9-9-05)

This year, film preservationist Grover Crisp came to the end of a long journey. He was able to unveil a new version of Major Dundee, a film long regarded as a mutilated masterpiece by fans of maverick director Sam Peckinpah.

Film historian David Thomson calls the Civil War drama starring Charlton Heston and Richard Harris "a broken thing" because of the way it was cut after Peckinpah lost his fight to see it released in its original form in 1965.

The beautifully restored new edition being unveiled on DVD this week by Sony Home Entertainment is still not complete. Crisp, the vice-president of film restoration for Sony, calls the new release "the extended version."

"This is definitely not the ultimate final director's version," he said by phone from Los Angeles. That's because some of the footage hacked away 40 years ago has been deemed irretrievable.

But Crisp is excited over what he did unearth. And...

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 13:35

SOURCE: Independent (UK) (9-9-05)

It's 100 years since Greta Lovisa Gustafson was born in the Southern Maternity Hospital in Stockholm. It has been 15 years since her death and more than 60 since she retired from acting, but no one seems any closer to unravelling the enigma of Greta Garbo. Just how did a plump shop assistant in a Stockholm department store become the brightest star in the MGM firmament? And what precisely did Garbo do with her time during that immense hiatus between her final film, Two-Faced Woman, in 1941, and her death in 1990?

The film-maker and historian Kevin Brownlow, whose new documentary Garbo (co-directed with Christopher Bird) was commissioned to mark the centenary, acknowledges that the life of the actress remains shrouded in mystery. He tells about his one near-encounter with his subject. He spotted Garbo, in a street in New York, laden with supermarket bags. At the time, he was desperate to speak to her for a series he was making about Hollywood. 'I tried hard to meet her, but...

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 13:30

SOURCE: The Irish Times (9-9-05)

Historians here have distorted the historical record for the past 30 years by propagating the State's "reinterpretation" of its foundation which involved Eamon de Valera being painted as "a dictator" and Michael Collins as a constitutionalist protecting democracy, a leading Scottish historian has argued.

This reinterpretation was propagated "not because it was good history but because it was politically expedient to do so", said Dr John Regan of the University of Dundee.

The imposition of a democratic narrative on the formation of the State demanded the generation of a historiography venerating the State and sometimes indulging in the rhetoric of achievement "without fully bringing to bear rigorous historical faculties". The modernisation of Irish history had faltered after 1970.

Addressing a conference at University College, Dublin, marking the 30th anniversary of the death of Eamon de Valera, Dr Regan said...

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 08:59

SOURCE: South China Morning Post (9-9-05)

Captain Cook: British imperial bully or benevolent explorer? It is a question that historians have been debating for decades, and which is now being tackled by one of Sydney's leading museums.

A new exhibition at the Museum of Sydney, titled "Cook's Sites", consists of a dozen contemporary photographs of places Cook visited during his three voyages of discovery around the Pacific. The photographs are enormous, several metres wide, and are contrasted with sketches and paintings of the same views produced by Cook's official artists more than 200 years ago.
...
Cook has long been regarded as the founding father of white settlement in Australia and New Zealand. Australia's national anthem, Advance Australia Fair, originally contained the unashamedly jingoistic verse:

When gallant Cook from Albion sailed,

To trace wide oceans o'er,

True British courage bore him on,

'Til he landed on our shore.

But...

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 08:46

SOURCE: Toronto Star (9-9-05)

A Mexican army convoy rolled into the United States yesterday with food, water and medicine for Hurricane Katrina victims, the first Mexican military operation on U.S. soil since 1916.

The convoy of 45 vehicles and some 200 troops is part of an aid package that includes ships and rescue teams.
...
Mexican forces under revolutionary Gen. Francisco (Pancho) Villa, angry at U.S. support for a rival, staged a small raid into New Mexico in 1916.

They were the bedraggled remnants of an army faction on the losing side of the Mexican revolution, but their action is seen by historians as the last military incursion into the United States.

The Villa troops killed several people on a raid on Columbus, New Mexico, prompting Washington to send a larger force into Mexico in retaliation.

The two countries fought a full-blown war in the mid-19th century, when the United States took what are now its southwestern states from Mexico.

Friday, September 9, 2005 - 08:39

SOURCE: The Guardian (London) (9-8-05)

The title of this exhibition is a bit misleading. Forgotten Empire, the British Museum calls its spectacular resurrection of ancient Persia. Yet the Persians are as notorious in their way as Darth Vader, the Sheriff of Nottingham, General Custer, or any other embodiment of evil empire you care to mention. They are history's original villains.

In its day, which lasted from the middle of the 500s BC until the defeat of Darius III by Alexander the Great in 331 BC, the Persian empire ruled a vast portion of the then-known world from the Nile to the Indus. It connected the Mediterranean with modern Afghanistan. Rich beyond dreams, powerful beyond dispute, the great kings ruled from their mighty palaces at Susa and Persepolis, tolerating the religions and cultures of subject peoples and harvesting the creativity of near eastern civilisation that had already, before they came along, invented writing and urban life. ...

The most vivid portrait of a Persian ruler isn't...

Thursday, September 8, 2005 - 12:34

SOURCE: Newsday (New York) (9-8-05)

THE WIDOW OF THE SOUTH, By Robert Hicks. Warner, 409 pp., $24.95.

Shelby Foote was not the greatest Civil War historian of his generation, but he was the best Civil War talker. Just after he died this year, Fresh Air, Terry Gross' public radio show, rebroadcast an interview with him. It was mesmerizing - the gentle Southern voice, the quiet authority, the personal connection to the war and to the South.

Then there were Foote's instant replies to the big questions. Years of study and contemplation had given him the ability to crystallize the cold logic of the Civil War. When Gross asked why so many battles had led to such horrible slaughter, Foote had the answer. It was, he said, because the weaponry was so superior to the tactics.

This explains the rebel turkey shoot at Fredericksburg, Va., its counterpart on the third day at Gettysburg and the carnage at Cold Harbor, Va. It also is the key to the battle at Franklin, Tenn., in which Confederate Gen...

Thursday, September 8, 2005 - 12:31

SOURCE: USA Today (9-8-05)

The Saints went marching out, an apt metaphor of Hurricane Katrina, even though it was part of football's footnote to the disaster. The New Orleans Saints played their NFL home games in the Superdome and thus needed a new home. For now, at least, the team's headquarters will be in San Antonio. Meanwhile, more important, hundreds of Pee Wee, high school and college football teams, as well as other fall sports, have also been displaced.


With Americans drowning in their attics, the postponement or relocation of games might seem trivial. But it's not. These games do need to go on.


"Sports needs to be restored as quickly as possible," says Ronald Kamm, immediate past president of the International Society for Sports Psychiatry. "It reduces stress, bonds people and offers a veneer of normalcy."


It might be only a veneer, but it's a critical one in the hurricane's swath -- Southern states where the passion for football...

Thursday, September 8, 2005 - 11:54

What if? This is one of the most intriguing aspects of history. The argument as to whether Australia was ever on Imperial Japanese drawing boards has raged since Pearl Harbour.

Last week, the vociferous Dr Peter Stanley, principal historian for the Australian War Memorial, produced a paper

designed to shout down anyone who believes Imperial Japan intended to invade Australia.

The answer is more complex than Dr Stanley points out.

It's unlikely a full-blown appreciation of an Australian invasion was ever put together, but that doesn't mean Imperial Japan didn't think about it.

Let's have a look at what happened back in '42. The speed with which the Japanese took the Pacific by the throat made everyone's head spin -- particularly the Japanese.

It was a bit of a surprise when, one after the other, massive colonial garrisons in Hong Kong, the Philippines and Singapore fell over to a poorly equipped and overstretched...

Thursday, September 8, 2005 - 11:34

SOURCE: Huffington Post (9-4-05)

My mother always told me that when a person dies, one should not say anything bad about him. My mother was wrong. History requires truth, not puffery or silence, especially about powerful governmental figures. And obituaries are a first draft of history.

So here's the truth about Chief Justice Rehnquist you won't hear on Fox News or from politicians. Chief Justice William Rehnquist set back liberty, equality, and human rights perhaps more than any American judge of this generation. His rise to power speaks volumes about the current state of American values.

Let's begin at the beginning. Rehnquist bragged about being first in his class at Stanford Law School. Today Stanford is a great law school with a diverse student body, but in the late 1940s and early 1950s, it discriminated against Jews and other minorities, both in the admission of students and in the selection of faculty. Justice Stephen Breyer recalled an earlier period of Stanford's history: "When...

Wednesday, September 7, 2005 - 18:56

SOURCE: NYT (9-6-05)

... That Chief Justice Rehnquist was unlike both puritanical conservatives like Warren E. Burger and movement conservatives like Antonin Scalia was evident in the character of his questions in the two gay rights cases I argued in the mid-1980's, one about firing teachers for "advocating" homosexual activity and the other about prosecuting consenting adults for same-sex intimacy. In neither case did his questions have the "I'm shocked" tenor of Chief Justice Burger's contribution to the dialogue. Justice Rehnquist simply pressed me appropriately on the absence of evidence that the challenged school board regulation had "ever been applied to a single living soul." And when I argued that consenting adults have a fundamental right to engage privately in the sex acts of their choice, while Chief Justice Burger and Justice Byron R. White could barely contain their disgust, Justice Rehnquist calmly pursued the question of just when and how that "fundamental...

Tuesday, September 6, 2005 - 17:34

... [T]here's little dispute that President Bill Clinton got it right when he named James Lee Witt as the FEMA Director in 1993. As amazing as it sounds, Witt was the first FEMA head who came to the position with direct experience in emergency management, having previously served as the Director of the Arkansas Office of Emergency Services for four years.

Witt was among the many Arkansas friends and associates of Clinton who accompanied the President to Washington during his first , term. At the start, however, Witt seemed among the least likely to become a major player in the Administration.

FEMA haq been labeled a "political dumping ground" in one Congressional report, and Senator Ernest F. Hollings, a Democrat from South Carolina, had called the agency "the sorriest bunch of bureaucratic jackasses" he had ever known.

The public and press also held FEMA in low regard, primarily because of how the agency had handled two big...

Tuesday, September 6, 2005 - 14:38

SOURCE: Slate (9-4-05)

The Rehnquist Court belongs to history. William H. Rehnquist will likely be seen as one of the three most influential chief justices in history, surpassed perhaps only by John Marshall and Earl Warren. Whether that influence was, on balance, benign will be one of history's great debates.

There will be little dispute that Rehnquist was a great leader and effective administrator of the Supreme Court and the national judiciary. He ran a tight ship in the great marble temple that houses the court. Every justice with whom I have spoken in recent years has noted that the court was functioning well under his leadership. Because of the power of his intellect—many law clerks thought him the smartest justice on a generally smart court—he quickly grasped the key issues in each of the complex and numerous cases that came before the court. As a consequence, he was able to lead the court's discussions in conference with efficiency and dispatch. Some colleagues thought he presided over...

Sunday, September 4, 2005 - 20:41

SOURCE: Slate (9-4-05)

... Rehnquist was appointed by Richard Nixon to the Supreme Court as an associate justice in 1971 and elevated to chief justice by Ronald Reagan in 1986. Those hearings were marked by accusations that the young Rehnquist had authored a memo, while clerking for Justice Robert Jackson in 1952, advocating for the constitutionality of segregation. He was similarly charged with having intimidated black voters at polling places in Arizona in the 1960s. What Rehnquist didn't do in response to those charges was what Clarence Thomas did: He didn't become bitter, or reclusive, or vengeful. Rehnquist denied them, then moved on, and—for the most part—the public did too.

Rehnquist's early writings could have melted paint. In 1973, when he and Byron White were the only dissenters in Roe v. Wade, his language was uncompromising: "To reach its result, the Court necessarily has had to find within the scope of the Fourteenth Amendment a right that was apparently completely unknown to...

Sunday, September 4, 2005 - 20:39

SOURCE: The Australian (9-3-05)

OUTSIDE Portland in Victoria is a place named Convincing Ground. No one knows the reason for the name but recently it gained a reputation as the bloodiest massacre site in Australian history, a conflict with whalers in which, according to The Age and the National Trust, between 60 and 200 Aborigines died.

This version of what would be a textbook massacre was created by selectively reading a few bits of paper. The good news is that it probably never happened. Let's review the facts.

One day in 1835, Portland pioneer Edward Henty walked along the beach to Convincing Ground. The entry in his diary is the first recorded use of the placename.

In 1836 explorer Thomas Mitchell visited Portland. He was told that Aborigines and whalers were sharing the carcasses of beached whales. Only some of the head material was taken by the whalers because removal of the rest was "too tedious".

The remainder was left for the Aborigines, who had...

Sunday, September 4, 2005 - 19:52

SOURCE: NYT (9-3-05)

Year Senate Judiciary Committee report on a Supreme Court nominee first published: 1916

Year Senate floor debate on a Supreme Court nomination first opened to public: 1929

Number of nominees who appeared before Senate Judiciary Committee before 1925: 0 (Harlan Fiske Stone was the first)

Number of nominees refused permission to speak before the committee: 1 (John Parker, 1930, later rejected)

Average time between nomination and Senate action on nominees in 19th century: 1 week

Average time between nomination and Senate action on nominees in last third of 20th century: 9 weeks


Sunday, September 4, 2005 - 12:47

SOURCE: South China Morning Post (9-1-05)

The Communist Party demands that it be the centrepiece for the commemoration of "the 60th anniversary of the victory in the anti-fascist war". Its launch in Hong Kong was attended by Secretary for Justice Elsie Leung Oi-sie, veteran patriot Xu Simin and an array of uniformed People's Liberation Army officers. It's hard to imagine that it's all about a film featuring Tony Leung Ka-fai.

On the Mountain of Tai Hang depicts what the mainland's official war historians see as a crucial period in the eight-year anti-Japanese struggle. Set in the first three years of the war, the movie portrays how Red Army commander-in-chief Zhu De swept into Shanxi province and prevented a Japanese victory in a region left with only depleted Kuomintang units as defence.

The bombastic rhetoric that accompanies the film is explained when the credits roll: the master-mind behind the epic is none other than Bayi Film Production Factory, the filmmaking wing of the People's...

Thursday, September 1, 2005 - 20:08

It is one of the most troubling puzzles in the history of political thought: Why were some of Europe's early liberal theorists -- the people who imagined and promoted tolerance, universal suffrage, the rule of law, and minimal government -- also enthusiastic supporters of European colonization, conquest, and empire in Asia and Africa?

John Stuart Mill, author of On Liberty and The Subjection of Women, spent 25 years working for the British East India Company in the mid-19th century. He believed that India and other "barbarous" nations "have not got beyond the period during which it is likely to be to their benefit that they should be conquered and held in subjection by foreigners." Alexis de Tocqueville, among the century's most sophisticated proponents of democracy, argued during the 1840s that it was urgently necessary for France to subjugate and colonize Algeria....

Two of the most visible exponents of [a] ... new wave in empire studies...

Thursday, September 1, 2005 - 18:34