George Mason University's
History News Network
New entry

Liberty & Power: Group Blog



Aeon J. Skoble
I still haven't found the time to write a long tribute to Star Trek on its 40th anniversary, but this NYT op-ed is pretty good, esp. the first two thirds or so.

Tuesday, September 19, 2006 - 07:45


David T. Beito
I have often disagreed with Raimondo but his defense of Pope Benedict has much merit.

Monday, September 18, 2006 - 11:05


Keith Halderman
Ex-Congressman Bob Barr continues to transform me (see here, here, and here) from foe to fan with some excellent commentary in today's Washington Times concerning the Center for Science in the Public Interest’s (CSPI) war on our food choices. In the piece Barr points out that "CSPI does not conduct actual scientific research. Instead, it is a public policy advocacy group. The organization wants the public to assume it does research, when what it really does is troll through thousands of scientific journals to pinpoint research that supports its pre-existing political agenda."

I wonder, though, if Bob Barr realizes that the current impulse for more government control of the food supply is in fact a mere extension of the war on people who use certain kinds of drugs? The arguments for restricting food choices are philosophically exactly the same as those for restricting drug choices. It is worth mentioning that after the passage of the 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act one of the first things the Bureau of Chemistry head, Harvey Wiley, did was to unilaterally prohibit coca as a food additive. The result, a myriad of harmless products were denied to the people that had enjoyed them.


Monday, September 18, 2006 - 21:06


David T. Beito
The greatest champion of free speech at the dawn of the twentieth century was born on this day in 1864.

Sunday, September 17, 2006 - 13:09


Steven Horwitz
Our own Jason Kuznicki has a great post on the morality of Wal-Mart over at Positive Liberty. Check it out.

Saturday, September 16, 2006 - 13:41


David T. Beito

The decision of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) to take on an academic freedom case at Bellevue Community College in Washington is welcome news. A byproduct is to publicize the many abuses inflicted by the college's program of mandatory diversity training.

As already discussed here, the college has signed a contract with Glenn Singleton's firm, Pacific Educational Group, which typically receives six figures for its"diversity training" services. Part of the deal is a requirement that faculty attend"Courageous Conservations" seminars on racism.

In addition to ensuring a captive audience to hear Singleton's peculiar interpretation of Huckleberry Finn, these seminars invite comparisons to the methods used during the Chinese Cultural Revolution. For example, participants in"Courageous Conversations" typically have to humiliate themselves by wearing signs showing numerical scores that reveal the extent of their alleged racism.

Hopefully, the new publicity will lead the faculty at Bellevue Community College to finally say enough is enough and tell Singleton and his associates to pack up and go home.


Friday, September 15, 2006 - 08:58


Common Sense
I like how USA Today refers to the fiat money as the"real" "real" money.

Friday, September 15, 2006 - 14:11


David T. Beito
The latest Washington Monthly features several articles from" conservatives," including Joe Scarborough, Bruce Fein, William Niskanen, and Bruce Bartlett, centered on the theme that it is "Time for Us to Go."

It may be well past"time" in a moral sense but will it actually happen? I am dubious. Much as the Bush administration richly deserves a black eye for its statist sins, I suspect that the GOP will hold its own in November.

The first signs of a Republican rebound are all around. Oil prices seem likely to fall even more and Bush could well contain the mess in Iraq for a few more months because of his deployment of additional troops (now about 145,000!).


Thursday, September 14, 2006 - 15:20


Sudha Shenoy
As I mentioned in my earlier post (below), these Archives contain millions of notarial documents -- the raw materials of Louisiana (& other) history. But AP report that troops _refused_ entry to equipment essential to salvaging the documents. I have emailed the following about this:
The Federal Preservation Officer in charge of such rescue:- John Ketchum (john.ketchum@fema.gov) (see David Beito’s comment.)
The Chairman of the Preservation Section, Society of American Archivists:- Gregor Trinkaus-Randall (gregor.trinkaus-randall@state.mass.us). The President of the SAA:- Richard Pearce-Moses (president@archivists.org). Its Executive Director:- Nancy Beaumont (nbeaumont@archivists.org).
The Heritage Emergency National Task Force (taskforce@heritagepreservation.org) -- they ask on their website for such information.

Quite possibly senior officers of the OAH, the AHA, & the Southern Historical Association should also be informed.

Hurricane Katrina caused a great human tragedy. After whatever help one can give there, I suggest the above should also be tackled. Please email one or more.

Wednesday, September 13, 2006 - 05:12


Sheldon Richman
Robert Higgs, author of Crisis and Leviathan and other important books, is the 2006 winner of the Thomas Szasz Award for Outstanding Contributions to the Cause of Civil Liberties (general category). Higgs joins a distinguished list of winners that includes Karl Hess, Phil Zimmermann (author of Pretty Good Privacy, the encryption program for everyone), and James Bovard.

Higgs is Senior Fellow in Political Economy at the Independent Institute; editor of its quarterly,The Independent Review; and a columnist for The Freeman.

Winner of the award in the professional category is Robert Spillane of Australia. Spillane is a psychologist who has fought against psychiatric abuses, particularly the drugging of children. He is the author of nine books.

Szasz of course is the leading defender of individual liberty against the various opppressions that fall in the category he has dubbed the Therapeutic State. (For more information, see my Szasz in One Lesson.)

No one is more deserving of this award. Congratulations, Bob!

(Full disclosure: I am a member of the awards commitee.)

Cross-posted at Free Association.

Wednesday, September 13, 2006 - 06:12


Sheldon Richman
From yesterday's Washington Post:
For decades, marriages between Sunnis and Shiites in Iraq were as ordinary as the daily call to prayer. But the sectarian warfare gripping the country has created a powerful barrier to Sunni-Shiite romances.

Married couples have filed for divorce rather than face the scorn of their neighbors. Fiances have split up as a result of death threats. And, increasingly, young single Iraqis have concluded that it is simply easier to stick to their own kind when it comes to love and family.

In a country where intermarriage was long considered the glue that held a fragile multi-ethnic society together, the romantic segregation of Sunnis and Shiites is more than just a reflection of the ever more hate-filled chasm between the two groups. It is also a grim foreboding of the future.
See what's happening? The Bush policy in Iraq is promoting . . . same-sect marriage!

Cross-posted at Free Association.

Wednesday, September 13, 2006 - 06:14


Amy H. Sturgis
The first recipients of the American Indian Youth Literature Award include a book on the Vermont Eugenics Program. Hidden Roots is written by Joseph Bruchac and published by Scholastic Press. The book is set within the historical framework of the Vermont Eugenics Program, a Native American sterilization program in the 1930s, and tells the story of the haunting effects of this shameful and tragic deed on one of the Abenaki families victimized by it. Author of more than 70 books for adults and children, Bruchac is of Abenaki ancestry and is a nationally recognized professional storyteller living in Greenfield Center, New York.

The American Indian Library Association (AILA), an affiliate of the American Library Association (ALA), is pleased to announce the first recipients of its American Indian Youth Literature Award. This new literary award was created as a way to identify and honor the very best writing and illustrations by and about American Indians. Books selected to receive the award present Native Americans in the fullness of their humanity in the present and past contexts.

The award is presented in each of three categories-picture book, middle school, and young adult-and each winner receives $500 and a commemorative plaque, which will be presented during the Joint Conference of Librarians of Color’s (JCLC) Children’s Luncheon program in Dallas on October 13 at noon.

"We are thrilled to have this opportunity to honor authors and illustrators who best portray Native American culture for young readers," said Victor Schill, co-chair, AILA American Indian Youth Literature Award committee."The rich literary heritage of this nation includes the oral and printed stories of its indigenous peoples. American Indian literature always has been and continues to be an integral part of our literary tapestry."

Beaver Steals Fire: A Salish Coyote Story, by the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, illustrated by Sam Sandoval, and published by the University of Nebraska Press is the winner for the picture book category. Accompanied by rich watercolor illustrations, the text relates a culturally vital tale from the Salish people of Montana about the significance of the gift of fire and how it should be respected.

Louise Erdrich is the winner of the middle-school award for The Birchbark House, published by Hyperion Books for Children. Setting her book in the middle 19th century, Erdrich paints a detailed portrait of Ojibwa life through the experiences of 7-year-old Omakayas who lives on the Island of the Golden Breasted Woodpecker on Lake Superior. The Birchbark House was Erdrich’s first novel for young readers, and the first book she has illustrated. She is a member of the Turtle Mountain Band of Ojibwa and lives with her two daughters in Minnesota.

The young adult award is Hidden Roots, written by Joseph Bruchac and published by Scholastic Press. The book is set within the historical framework of the Vermont Eugenics Program, a Native American sterilization program in the 1930s, and tells the story of the haunting effects of this shameful and tragic deed on one of the Abenaki families victimized by it. Author of more than 70 books for adults and children, Bruchac is of Abenaki ancestry and is a nationally recognized professional storyteller living in Greenfield Center, New York.

To register to attend the presentation of the American Indian Youth Literature Award, please visit the JCLC Web site at www.ala.org/jclc . Advance registration for the JCLC ends September 8, 2006.

In the near future an American Indian Youth Literature Award free downloadable bookmark and brochure will be made available on the AILA Web site at www.nativeculturelinks.com/aila.html .

Members of the American Indian Youth Literature Award are: Naomi Caldwell, co-chair, GSLIS, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, R.I.; Victor L. Schill, co-chair, Harris County Public Library, Houston; Carlene Engstrom, D’Arcy McNickle Library, Salish Kootenai College, Pablo, Mont.; and Gabriella Kaye, Mashantucket, Pequot Museum & Research Center, Mashantucket, Conn.


Monday, September 11, 2006 - 09:24


Roderick T. Long
Some thoughts on the 9/11 anniversary here.

Some thoughts on Foucault on power relations here.

Monday, September 11, 2006 - 16:27


Steven Horwitz
This LA Times story about Wal-Mart entering into a partnership with the National Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce provides a good example of a trying to create controversy where there is none and insufficient critical thinking by the reporter.

The theme of the story is best summarized in this sentence:"But not all of its usual supporters — nor some gay activists — welcomed the announcement." This first part is a reference to conservative groups who normally support Wal-Mart now being upset by their"anti-family" stance in partnering with the NGLCC. No surprise there. But what about the"gay activists" opposing the partnership? On what grounds would they do so?

Later we read:

Just as black leaders have disagreed about whether to work with the company because of what critics call miserly pay and benefits, not all gay and lesbian groups believe the alliance is positive.

"Our community is a smart community, and we can see a shameless marketing opportunity when it comes," said Jeremy Bishop, program director of Pride at Work, a group within the AFL-CIO that represents gay and lesbian workers.

"For us it's a matter of social and economic justice, and Wal-Mart has a long record of not treating its employees — gay or straight — with equity and dignity."

So the only"gay activist" quoted in the story is, in fact, at least as much a union activist as a"gay activist." So despite the story's opening premise that"some gay activists" are critical of this partnership, in fact, only one appears to be. And that"one" is part of a group who has long opposed Wal-Mart for a whole variety of reasons.

Is it too much to ask that the reporter at least note that the AFL-CIO has a long history of opposing everything Wal-Mart has done, given their resistance to unionization? Is it too much to ask that the premise of"some" gay activists be rendered more accurately as"a gay activist affiliated with a union long-opposed to Wal-Mart?"

My point here is not that there's some sort of political bias in the coverage. The real point is that the reporter tried to create controversy where there wasn't any, overstated the degree of opposition by gay activists in order to do so, and then didn't provide full context for the one gay activist opposing the partnership. It's just sensationalism and sloppy reporting that has the effect of making Wal-Mart look worse than necessary for doing something good.

Sunday, September 10, 2006 - 10:35


Gus diZerega
Rodney Balko has released a new book, Overkill: The Rise of Paramilitary Police Raids in America. Read about it here.
The book is important for two reasons. First, it has an disturbing story to tell of how the police can and do break into SAmericans' homes and kill them, even when innocent, with no reprucussions.

Second, for those so-called classical liberals who still, insanely, provide excuses for the right wingers they think of as erring allies, consider the probable reaction of the Republican Party to Balko's book compared to Daily Kos which praises the book. Kos, of course, is the prime site for what is now called the left wing of the Democratic Party.

Sunday, September 10, 2006 - 13:38


Sheldon Richman
When government began controlling narcotics nearly 90 years ago, it assured Americans it would never interfere with the practice of medicine.

Chalk up another in a long series of lies by the state. In theory government serves the people. In practice it does something else entirely.

The crusade to determine what drugs we can and cannot use, and under what conditions, couldn't help but affect medical practice. Someone who wanted a drug controlled by the state had two ways to obtain it: he could go into the black market or go to a doctor. If the drug-enforcement agencies weren’t prepared to watch the doctors, how effective could the anti-drug policy be? So as time went on, they did watch the doctors -- and prosecuted them, ruining careers and sending some to jail in the process.

Read the rest of this week's TGIF column at the Foundation for Economic Education website.

Cross-posted at Free Association.

Saturday, September 9, 2006 - 08:06


Roderick T. Long

[cross-posted at Austro-Athenian Empire]

My article “Rule-following, Praxeology, and Anarchy,” which I presented last April at the PCPE in Prague, has just been published in the Liberální Institut’s journal New Perspectives on Political Economy. I argue that Wittgenstein’s rule-following paradox has implications both for Austrian methodology and for anarchist theory. Czech it out.

In a recent column, Sheldon Richman, citing my article, suggests some implications for our understanding of the Constitution as well.


Saturday, September 9, 2006 - 18:59


Aeon J. Skoble
40 years ago today, Star Trek premiered. I don't have time to write the long appreciation that it deserves (Amy? Roderick?), but at its best, it was great science fiction television. When I was watching it as a kid growing up, I learned a lot from it about optimism, and human potential, and diversity (IDIC!), and so on. I can still answer trivia questions and recite dialogue, without cheating with the internet. I confess I never warmed up to the overly PC (and frequently derivative) Next Gen, or any of the subsequent spinoffs, and was underwhelmed by all the films. And the original show had it's share of silliness, most often in the third season. But it was great stuff. Perhaps next week I'll have a chance to write more, but I couldn't let the anniversary slip by unnoticed. Comments welcome, but I'd really prefer not to get into flamey arguments about Next Gen etc. UPDATE: This, however, is surely a bad idea. Assassins!!

Friday, September 8, 2006 - 09:33


David T. Beito
Check it out.

Thursday, September 7, 2006 - 12:02


David T. Beito
In this video, Tucker Carlson, who has described himself as a libertarian and a critic of the Iraq war, shows his mettle as a journalist. He thoroughly humiliates former rightwing (and current leftwing) hit-man, David Brock.

No doubt, the pro-war bloggers now praising Carlson's doggedness in this interview will soon flip-flop when he gives one of their heroes the same treatment.

Beautifully executed.


Thursday, September 7, 2006 - 18:31