How Ronald Reagan Reinvented Religion
But what exactly was the nature of Reagan's religious beliefs? The striking thing about his sense of religion is how much it enables us to forget religion. On this subject the radical Left has had it all wrong.
In the 1960s, when Reagan was governor of California, activist students assumed he was a reactionary conservative who would find himself in thrall to the fundamentalist Right that was sprouting in Orange County. But those who advocated"participatory democracy" in the expectation it would lead to socialism faced a Reaganite conservativism advocating popular democracy to bring capitalism to fruition. It was tempting for the New Left to dismiss the religion of the American Right as the"opium of the people," a set of beliefs that promised to relieve what Marx called the"sigh of the oppressed." In Reagan's America, the Left saw religion as repressive, distorting the people's deepest yearning for freedom and the fulfillment of humanity's every need and wish. The guru of the era was Herbert Marcuse, the German emigre and author of One-Dimensional Man, a text that taught the students of Reagan's sunny California that not only the mind but the body itself had been crippled by Christianity, denying its desires for the"polymorphous perverse," sex any which way. No one seemed to notice how Reagan transformed religion from the governor's podium and later from the president's pulpit. Redefining the nature of desire, Reagan's religion would deny nothing because life offered everything. Our beliefs about God no longer repress but liberate, as though Christ died on the Cross so that we might better pursue happiness, not the salvation of our souls.
Reagan's carefree attitude toward religion reminds one of America's great master of mockery, H. L. Mencken, who, in Treatise on the Gods, contrasted the nation's civil religion to the first Christian sects:
Observing a Roman cardinal dashing down Fifth avenue in his Rolls-Royce, with bands braying, drums rolling, and cops clearing his regal way, one forgets the rule of St. Benedict, and the sisters in the hospitals. One forgets, too, the Stylites on their pillars, the Dendrites roosting in trees, the Boskoi who ate only grass, the Euchites who prayed incessantly, the Trappists who never speak.
As Mencken noted, it is not what one believes about religion but what one forgets about it--the saints and the sinners.
President Reagan almost never left the White House to go to church, and he seldom invited a chaplain in to give services (though he attended church occasionally upon leaving office). Reagan defended religion against those who sought to purge it from public life, but he hardly wished to see Americans submit themselves to an ecclesiastical establishment. Conservatives who hold up the family as a source of authority hearken back to the seventeenth-century monarchist Robert Filmer, whether they know it or not. Filmer had justified the"divine right" of kings with such reasoning. Reagan's relations toward his own children reveal a man who would not see the young suffer from patriarchal or churchly repression, or from any inhibitions alien to their own being. As his family letters indicate, he tried to advise his children based on his own experiences with life, but he did not preach or pontificate. He advised his son Michael that infidelity is a natural impulse but perilous to genuine love; he did not browbeat young Ron when he told his father that he had lost his faith; he taught his daughter Patti how to improve her essay on Bonnie and Clyde without seeming to mind the film's erotic content.
In his campaign speeches, Reagan asked Americans whether or not they were"better off," and he assured his followers that his economic programs intended to"let the people flourish," establishing a criterion for American politics that was as far from conventional religion as was imaginable. He made comfort and pleasure, not conviction and piety, the measure of all things. Two centuries earlier, when the historian Edward Gibbon asked whether Christianity did anything to contribute to the happiness of Roman civilization, he had to be reminded that Jesus' message offered a way to rise above the longing for material possessions, and it had nothing to do with being"better off." Like Thomas Jefferson, Ronald Reagan revered Jesus of Nazarus as an oracle of moral wisdom. While Jefferson denied the divinity of Christ and Reagan upheld it, however, neither political leader believed that the meek shall inherit the earth or that the self was the seed of sin. One president could not stay away from Sally Hemings, the other would not chase the money changers from the temple.
Conservatives who are convinced that America is fundamentally a religious country like to quote Tocqueville to the effect that the"tie" of religion is what binds America together, and if that tie is broken, all is lost. Tocqueville indeed says as much in Democracy in America, calling religion"the first of American political institutions." He also advised, however, that neither the Christian principle of sacrifice nor the political ideal of classical virtue dares stand in the way of modernity. What, then, binds America together?"What serves as a tie to these diverse elements?" Tocqueville wrote to a friend of the riddle of America's fragmented social order."What makes of them a people? Interest. That's the secret. Individual interest which sticks through at each instant, interest which, moreover, comes out in the open and calls itself a social theory."
comments powered by Disqus
Jason Blake Keuter - 6/6/2007
reagan raped and murdered nuns in south america? was he inspired by the rape and murder of nuns in el salvador, somewhat north of the area where reagan went to work?
Lorraine Paul - 6/5/2007
How anyone could defend Reagan's 'evil administration' is beyond my ken.
From his days of spying on fellow actors as President of the Screen Actors' Guild, to the rape and murder of four American nuns in South America; both foreign and domestic policy pushed by Reagan should only earn disgust and abhorrence, certainly not praise.
Mr Whitener, how short is your memory? Have you forgotten that RR's administration was found guilty of the charge of terrorism against the nation state of Nicaragua? Rather than attempting to undermine Professor Diggins, you should be applauding his courage in refusing to bow to the 'official story'!
Ray Whitener - 6/4/2007
My response to Tim Matthewson's brickbats is simply "There you go again". Sound familiar eh? Regurgitating bits a pieces of an eight year admisistation does not sway me one bit. President Reagan earned the respect of the American people and world leaders.
As for reinventing Religion, he answered the call of many looking for a man unafraid of defining America in the world.
Tim Matthewson - 6/4/2007
Ronald Reagan was a small town lifeguard and "B" movie actor who would have been impeached and removed from office had he not been suffered from Alzheimer's disease. By the time he left office, he could not even recognize the faces of the members of his own cabinet and could not remember much of what he had done during his presidency.
Following the investigations of the Tower commission, which examined the Iran-Contra scandal, ten members of his administration were convicted and served jail time. Casper Weinberger his secretary of defense would have served jail time, had be not been pardoned by President GHW Bush. Reagan repeatedly denied that he had traded arms for hostages in Iran. Many of his critics claimed that he had lied to the Tower commission, but he simply could not remember signing the presidential finding that had authorized members of his administration to negotiate with the Iranians and seek release of the hostages by paying for their release with arms shipments.
President Reagan was a highly partisan president who cynically used religion and manipulated the religious right to gain power and divide the American people. His words were always laced with divisive overtones that sought to identify the good guys and bad guys, a manachean tendency that he had learned from the movies, where he always wore the white hat.
As Tocqueville noted, politics has never been a major focus of the American people and the people who usually gone into politics in America have been people such as Reagan, who had failed at business or some other career. Reagan failed as a spokesman for GE following WWII; his views grew so extreme that he was fired by GE as a right wing extremist. He could not make it in the movies, so he went into politics, which as many have noted is show business for ugly people such as Reagan.
Reagan was an extremely lazy person who seldom if ever read anything if he could avoid it. His staff got into the habit of making video tapes for him because he refused to read the materials presented to him.
Reagan's memories were dominated by a vision of America as the small mid-western town where he had grown up and served as a lifeguard. But unlike all of his friends from small town America, he would not fight to defend America when called and he avoided military service in WWII.
His vision of small town America lent an exclusive bent to his biases and language. He remained a supporter of the apartheid regime in South Africa, but he was the last president to do so. When he vetoed a sanction's bill directed against the apartheid regime, the Black Caucus rallied the 2/3 vote in Congress to override the presidential veto, thus delivering a humiliating defeat to the president.
It was a defeat that showed who Ronald Reagan truly was as a person, a person who reveled in the exclusivity of small town America, who celebrated the whites only ambiance, who disliked black persons, Mexicans, Hyphenates, but who was a person who was too lazy to get up early on Sunday morning to go to church and who shared none of small town America's love of hard work, fidelity to one woman, the sanctity of marriage, and commitment to truth telling.
To make matters worse, his economic policies accelerated the decline of the middle class in America, started by Richard Nixon, as he secured the passage thru congress of tax policies that served the rich and saddle the middle class with an enormous debt designed to bankrupt the social policies that served the middle class such as student loans.
The claim that Reagan's policies led to the collapse of communism in Russia does not even rate the claims that it was a half truth. It was rejected by G.H.W. Bush who ran on the platform that Bush had caused the collapse of communism.
There is nothing to the claim that Reagan was a great or even a good president. He's at the bottom of the heap, right down there with James Buchanan.
- David Rosand, an Art History Scholar Whose Heart Was in Venice, Dies at 75
- NYT interviews Rick Perlstein about his book
- OAH issues a statement in support of the AP standards
- Daniel Pipes says in interview that the absence of anti-Israel protests in Muslim countries is highly significant
- A historian who studies China has discovered an overlooked angle in the debate about the Middle East. Could he have figured out a key reason for Iraq’s failure to defeat ISIS?